The general issue highlighted in the post "Critics rip Cell
paper"1 and many of the comments that followed is one of
"selective citation," in which papers fail to include all relevant prior art. I
believe that this example reached the current level of scrutiny because the
complainant, Peter Lawrence, is a well-known scientist and he was willing to raise a
public fuss when he felt that his work had been overlooked in a paper published in a
prominent journal.
The article you are attempting to read is Premium content which is only available to our online subscribers.
Subscribing to The Scientist is easy and inexpensive.
And you can choose from many options. Try us out with an online day pass starting at only $4.95. Or, get it all with unlimited online access to The Scientist Archive and door-to-door delivery of our monthly print magazine.
The Scientist also offers site licenses to institutions and organizations. When your librarian adds The Scientist to the library's collection, you can get unlimited online access through your place of work or study. Recommend The Scientist today
