Advertisement

Your Guide to Retraction and Non-Retraction Retractions

Your Guide to Retraction and Non-Retraction Retractions By Andrea Gawrylewski ARTICLE EXTRAS Glossary of retractions Judging by the press coverage of Woo-Suk Hwang and others in the past few years, you might be forgiven for thinking that study retractions are on the rise. At first blush, the data support that: Among the 5,020 journals in Medline, there were 97 retracted articles in 2006, which is almost four times the 25 in 1997. The climb has not been

By | March 1, 2007

Your Guide to Retraction and Non-Retraction Retractions

By Andrea Gawrylewski


ARTICLE EXTRAS

Glossary of retractions

Judging by the press coverage of Woo-Suk Hwang and others in the past few years, you might be forgiven for thinking that study retractions are on the rise. At first blush, the data support that: Among the 5,020 journals in Medline, there were 97 retracted articles in 2006, which is almost four times the 25 in 1997. The climb has not been consistent, however, with many years registering fewer retractions than the year before. For example, 1998 saw 53 retractions, but the following four years had less than 40 retractions each.

The picture, then, is a bit muddied. Even more confusing are the other classifications, including some with unclear meanings. Consider, for example, the term Expression of Concern Reaffirmed, which the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) used in 2005 to raise issues about some of the data on Vioxx. There's also a new official classification: Partial Retraction. We've canvassed the literature for terms that may or may not mean quite the same thing as a retraction. So here they are, including Expression of Concern Reaffirmed, in alphabetical order.

View Dictionary.

Advertisement
QIAGEN ingenuity
QIAGEN ingenuity

Popular Now

  1. First Data from Anti-Aging Gene Therapy
  2. The Two Faces of Fish Oil
    Notebook The Two Faces of Fish Oil

    The discovery of a tumor-protecting role for a fatty acid found in fish oil has sparked debate about the product’s safety.

  3. The Zombie Literature
    Features The Zombie Literature

    Retractions are on the rise. But reams of flawed research papers persist in the scientific literature. Is it time to change the way papers are published?

  4. Locating Language within the Brain
Advertisement
Advertisement
RayBioTech