Advertisement
MO BIO
MO BIO

Bacterial Rejuvenation

Bacteria age, but as a lineage, can live forever.

By | October 27, 2011

Dividing E. coliPUBLIC HEALTH IMAGE LIBRARY, JANICE HANEY CARR

Do bacteria age? Most biology textbooks will say that they don’t. However, research challenged that view for the first time in 2005, and a debate has ensued over the past 6 years. But a new model, published today (October 27) in Current Biology, re-examines earlier experiments and suggests that aging may have evolved early on as a mechanism that protects new generations from damages accrued by the parent.

When researchers look at aging in another single-celled  organism, budding yeast, it's easy to see that cell division is asymmetrical, with a large parent producing offspring that are much smaller in size. (The second, larger cell that results from cell division is still considered the parent.) Asymmetry in division is an important aspect of aging because it allows an organism to partition damaged proteins—the accumulation of which is a widely accepted proxy for cellular age—into one cell, the older cell, while giving the new cell a clean slate.  In bacteria, however, a mother divides into two identical-looking daughters through what was assumed to be symmetric division.

In 2005, Eric Stewart and colleagues, then at INSERM in France, showed that dividing bacteria produce two daughters that replicate at different rates—the first solid evidence for asymmetric division. When he first read the paper, Chao said, "it changed the way I looked at the world." The finding implied that one offspring was taking a hit, retaining the damaged proteins that prevented it from replicating as quickly as the other, "renewed" daughter cell. In other words, it was aging.  Chao started creating mathematical models to try to explain aging and produce predictions that could be tested to further validate Stewart and colleagues's data. But last year, another paper, published by some of the same researchers and led by Suckjoon Jun from Harvard University, came out  that contradicted part of the 2005 findings, and Chao wondered if his model might be able to explain both observations.  Jun's group had developed a system in which single E. coli bacterium could be grown and tracked on a microfluidics channel. They concluded that a "mother" bacterium could divide a hundred time and not show signs of aging.  E. coli, he wrote in the article, had "a robust mechanism of growth that is decoupled from cell death."

When Chao re-analyzed both studies, he realized both sets of data fit his mathematical model. The offspring of a mother that divided asymmetrically into faster and slower-growing daughters would have a higher overall fitness than a mother that divided symmetrically. In addition, while some offspring would reproduce faster than others, they would only speed up to a certain point—an equilibrium point.  The slow reproducing offspring, likewise wouldn't decrease reproduction rate indefinitely; they would never stop dividing altogether. So the lineage produced by the exponential divisions of a single cell could "reach a immortal state" despite the fact that it was dividing asymmetrically, and producing daughter cells that "age," said Chao.

Jun said that the model is interesting, but that it explains only a portion of his group's data. He also questioned the validity of comparing the data since the two groups grew the bacteria under quite different experimental conditions.

While the model has yet to be tested and verified experimentally, it proposes "interesting" ideas, and "makes testable predictions," said Stewart, who is now at Northeastern University, and was not involved in the research. The model suggests that aging may be an ancient phenomenon that confers a higher fitness to a lineage. "The implication is that when a cell cannot repair all of the damage, it gets rid of the damage," by dividing asymmetrically, said Stewart.

C.U. Rang et al., "Temporal Dynamics of Bacterial Aging and Rejuvenation," Current Biology, doi:10.1016/j.cub.2011.09.018, 2011.

Advertisement

Add a Comment

Avatar of: You

You

Processing...
Processing...

Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo

Comments

Avatar of: ridahoan

ridahoan

Posts: 1

October 27, 2011

Fascinating!  I'm not sure if the simple description of 'aging' is appropriate though.  Perhaps by partitioning the cellular state, these bacteria are also creating two daughter cells optimized for different metabolic and niche exploitation strategies:  the 'young' daughter is able to grow and divide quickly to take advantage of any favorable environment, while the 'old' daughter takes the senescent or wait and watch approach, perhaps repairing cellular damage in the meantime.

Avatar of:

Posts: 0

October 27, 2011

Fascinating!  I'm not sure if the simple description of 'aging' is appropriate though.  Perhaps by partitioning the cellular state, these bacteria are also creating two daughter cells optimized for different metabolic and niche exploitation strategies:  the 'young' daughter is able to grow and divide quickly to take advantage of any favorable environment, while the 'old' daughter takes the senescent or wait and watch approach, perhaps repairing cellular damage in the meantime.

Avatar of:

Posts: 0

October 27, 2011

Fascinating!  I'm not sure if the simple description of 'aging' is appropriate though.  Perhaps by partitioning the cellular state, these bacteria are also creating two daughter cells optimized for different metabolic and niche exploitation strategies:  the 'young' daughter is able to grow and divide quickly to take advantage of any favorable environment, while the 'old' daughter takes the senescent or wait and watch approach, perhaps repairing cellular damage in the meantime.

Avatar of:

Posts: 0

October 28, 2011

There is a potential artefact in the 2005 studies on bacterial ageing. The use of GFP and fluorescence imaging in those experiments can lead to damage in the putative "mother" cells that makes them appear to have aged. Until these studies can be repeated in a non-invasive manner (e.g. with microfluidics), they will have to be considered unverified.

Avatar of:

Posts: 0

October 28, 2011

There is a potential artefact in the 2005 studies on bacterial ageing. The use of GFP and fluorescence imaging in those experiments can lead to damage in the putative "mother" cells that makes them appear to have aged. Until these studies can be repeated in a non-invasive manner (e.g. with microfluidics), they will have to be considered unverified.

Avatar of: jsha

jsha

Posts: 2

October 28, 2011

There is a potential artefact in the 2005 studies on bacterial ageing. The use of GFP and fluorescence imaging in those experiments can lead to damage in the putative "mother" cells that makes them appear to have aged. Until these studies can be repeated in a non-invasive manner (e.g. with microfluidics), they will have to be considered unverified.

Follow The Scientist

icon-facebook icon-linkedin icon-twitter icon-vimeo icon-youtube
Advertisement

Stay Connected with The Scientist

  • icon-facebook The Scientist Magazine
  • icon-facebook The Scientist Careers
  • icon-facebook Neuroscience Research Techniques
  • icon-facebook Genetic Research Techniques
  • icon-facebook Cell Culture Techniques
  • icon-facebook Microbiology and Immunology
  • icon-facebook Cancer Research and Technology
  • icon-facebook Stem Cell and Regenerative Science
Advertisement
Advertisement
Life Technologies