EPA to Review Toxicity Ratings

Congress orders the Environmental Protection Agency to review the toxicity ratings of some chemicals and improve its process for making such assessments.

By | December 19, 2011


The Integrated Risk Information System (IRIS) is a database that stores assessments about the safety levels of various chemicals. The assessments, formalized by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), are based on scientific data, but the process—as well as the IRIS entries—have been widely criticized. A review of the EPA's assessment of formaldehyde by a National Academies’ National Research Council (NRC) panel, for example, insisted upon by Senator David Vitter (R-LA) in 2009 found there was not sufficient evidence to support the idea that formaldehyde causes leukemia, despite observations that workers exposed to the chemical are at an increased risk of death from the disease,  among other technical problems with the assessment.

The NRC panel suggested a number of changes to the EPA’s process of assessing chemical toxicity. In response, Congress has now ordered the EPA to adopt those recommendations in a new $915 billion 2012 spending bill, ScienceInsider reported. Among the requirements, the EPA must have the National Academies review draft assessment of inorganic arsenic, which could, as it’s currently written, impose an unnecessary burden on drinking water treatment, as well as assessments for up to two other chemicals.

“Overall, we're pleased that Congress has taken on the ongoing issues with IRIS,” Scott Jensen, a spokesperson for the American Chemistry Council in Washington, DC, told ScienceInsider. But not everyone agrees with the changes. “Sending reviews to the National Academies is a terrible idea that is unnecessary, costly, and will lead to lengthy delays,” added Jennifer Sass of the Natural Resources Defense Council. “EPA IRIS assessments are subjected to Agency staff review, interagency review, public comment, and expert peer review. There is nothing magical about the NAS review that could add to an already years' long process of review.”


Add a Comment

Avatar of: You



Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo
BD Biosciences
BD Biosciences

Popular Now

  1. The Mycobiome
    Features The Mycobiome

    The largely overlooked resident fungal community plays a critical role in human health and disease.

  2. Antibody Alternatives
    Features Antibody Alternatives

    Nucleic acid aptamers and protein scaffolds could change the way researchers study biological processes and treat disease.

  3. Holding Their Ground
    Features Holding Their Ground

    To protect the global food supply, scientists want to understand—and enhance—plants’ natural resistance to pathogens.

  4. Circadian Clock and Aging
    Daily News Circadian Clock and Aging

    Whether a critical circadian clock gene is deleted before or after birth impacts the observed aging-related effects in mice.

Life Technologies