BP Subpoenas Scientist Emails

Researchers who studied the Deep Water Horizon disaster have handed over 3,000 internal documents and emails to BP as part of the lawsuit that seeks damages from the oil company.

By | June 5, 2012

image: BP Subpoenas Scientist Emails Satellite image of the BP oil spill on June 26, 2010 NASA

Satellite image of the BP oil spill on June 26, 2010 NASA

Researchers at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute (WHOI) who estimated the size of the oil spill in spring 2010 have been caught in the cross fire as U.S. courts try to decide exactly how much to fine BP for the resulting environmental damage, causing many to express concern over academic freedoms. The presiding judge magistrate granted BP's request to access the private information.

The two researchers involved, Christopher Reddy and Richard Camilli, published an op-ed yesterday in the Boston Globe, in which they explained their concerns.

“Incomplete thoughts and half-finished documents attached to e-mails can be taken out of context and impugned by people who have a motive for discrediting the findings,” they wrote.

Reddy and Camilli said they had already provided BP with over 50,000 pages of reports and data that was sufficient for BP to confirm their calculations, and that the request for private emails constitutes “an erosion of the scientific deliberative process.”

The give-and-take, dead-ends, and skepticism that is a part of the exchange between scientists, they wrote, are essential to push research forward. But they can easily be misinterpreted, Reddy and Camilli added, as was the case with the leaked emails from the Climate Research Unit in 2009, sparking the so-called Climategate controversy.

“This situation casts a chill over the scientific process,” Reddy and Camilli wrote in their op-ed. “In future crises, scientists may censor or avoid deliberations, and more importantly, be reluctant to volunteer valuable expertise and technology that emergency responders don't possess. Open, scientific deliberation is critical to science.”


Add a Comment

Avatar of: You



Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo


Avatar of: RobertD


Posts: 1457

June 6, 2012

The collision of Science and the Law is seldom pretty, especially when large sums of money are at stake.

Popular Now

  1. Rethinking the Rise of Mammals
    Daily News Rethinking the Rise of Mammals

    Mammals diversified 30 million years later than previously estimated, according to a new analysis of an ancient fossil.

  2. Wiping Out Gut Bugs Stops Obesity
  3. Birth of the Skin Microbiome
    Daily News Birth of the Skin Microbiome

    The immune system tolerates the colonization of commensal bacteria on the skin with the aid of regulatory T cells during the first few weeks of life, a mouse study shows.

  4. Battling the Bulge
    Bio Business Battling the Bulge

    Weight-loss drugs that target newly characterized obesity-related receptors and pathways could finally offer truly effective fat control.

Life Technologies