Advertisement

The DSM-5 Alcohol Debate

The new version of the diagnostic manual will do away with alcohol dependence and abuse categories in favor of a single “alcohol use disorder” diagnosis.

By | June 7, 2012

image: The DSM-5 Alcohol Debate stock.xchng, jsanders

STOCK.XCHNG, JSANDERS

The fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5)—slated to be published in 2013—has been causing a stir in the psychiatric community over the proposed revisions to the previous edition. Now, that controversy continues with a new debate on how to diagnose alcohol and other substance use disorders.

Under the current DSM-IV guidelines, different criteria are used to determine whether a person has an alcohol dependence or an alcohol abuse problem. Under the new guidelines, however, the separate categories have been melded into a single "alcohol use disorder" diagnosis, which requires a person to meet two criteria out of a list of 11.

"Our goal was to try to make the criteria easier for the usual clinician to use, and so we're no longer asking them to remember one criteria set for abuse and a separate set for dependence," Marc Schuckit, who served as a member of the Substance Use Disorder Work Group for the DSM-5, said in a press release.

A major concern of the revision has been that it may lead to more people being diagnosed as having an alcohol use disorder—with a recent study published in Addiction predicting a 60 percent increase in the rate of alcohol-use disorders under the new diagnostic guidelines.

“The further watering down of definitional standards will make psychiatric diagnosis so ubiquitous as to be almost meaningless—and divert scarce resources away from those who do need them,” Allen Frances, professor emeritus at the department of psychiatry of Duke University School of Medicine and chair of the DSM-IV Task Force, wrote in a Psychology Today blog post.

But Schuckit asserts that an evaluation of more than 100,000 cases using both the DSM-IV and the DSM-5, did not result in a significant difference in the number of diagnoses.

Advertisement

Add a Comment

Avatar of: You

You

Processing...
Processing...

Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo
Advertisement

Popular Now

  1. Staying Active in the Lab
    Careers Staying Active in the Lab

    Retiring as a professor, and even shutting down your own lab, doesn’t necessarily mean quitting research.

  2. When Does a Smart Mouse Become Human?
  3. The Lies That Scars Tell
    Notebook The Lies That Scars Tell

    Macaque trainers in Bangladesh are often bitten by their monkeys, but rarely infected by a particular simian retrovirus.

  4. Antibiotic Resistance Can Boost Bacterial Fitness
Advertisement
NeuroScientistNews
NeuroScientistNews
Advertisement
The Scientist