Forensic Law Turns to Epigenetics

Privacy advocates are arguing that collecting genetic data upon arrest is an invasion of privacy, given recent evidence that 80 percent of the human genome is functional.

By | September 25, 2012

Christoph Bock, Max Planck Institute for Informatics" > Wikimedia Commons, Christoph Bock, Max Planck Institute for Informatics

In a case that challenges California’s practice of collecting DNA upon arrest, the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) is asking a court to consider the recently reported ENCODE project, which has stated that at least 80 percent of the human genome is functional, and should therefore be considered private information.

Much of the argument for DNA collection rested on the idea that the sections of the genome analyzed—the 13 markers that are part of state and national databases of DNA profiles from convicted offenders (CODIS)—would only reveal an individual’s identity and no other physical traits. But the new ENCODE findings suggest that even these regions may have a function, and could reveal sensitive information as a person’s disease susceptibility, among other personal traits.

However, since the ENCODE papers were released, a number of researchers have criticized how the results were publicized, and many researchers have taken issue with how the word “functional” was defined. In response, one of the ENCODE authors has stated that the word was meant to connote a sequence that was biochemically active and that a much smaller percentage of the genome is expected to be directly involved in gene regulation and thus likely play a role in disease and normal function. But law professor David Kaye at Penn State University questions the court’s ability to evaluate the questions being posed. “After the judges consider the ENCODE papers (by having their law clerks read them?), will they be better informed about the actual privacy implications of the CODIS loci than they were before this excursion into this realm of the bioinformatics?” he wrote on the blog, The Double Helix Law. “I would not bet on it, but maybe I am growing cynical.”

(Hat tip to GenomeWeb.)

Add a Comment

Avatar of: You

You

Processing...
Processing...

Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo

Popular Now

  1. A Potential Remedy for the Aging Brain
    The Scientist A Potential Remedy for the Aging Brain

    In mice, injected fragments of a naturally occurring protein boost memory in young and old animals and improve cognition and mobility in a model of neurodegenerative disease. 

  2. The Sleeping Brain Can Learn
    Daily News The Sleeping Brain Can Learn

    Humans can remember new sensory information presented during REM sleep, but this ability is suppressed during deep, slow-wave slumber.

  3. USDA Emails: Don’t Use “Climate Change”
  4. Nature Index Identifies Top Contributors to Innovation
AAAS