NYC Science Stunned by Sandy

Super storm Sandy wreaks havoc on researchers across New York City, destroying samples, killing lab animals, and cutting power to much of Manhattan.

By | November 2, 2012

Super storm Sandy caused a blackout across much of lower Manhattan.Wikimedia, David ShankboneFlooding and blackouts caused by super storm Sandy have had a devastating impact on scores of scientists in the Big Apple, with one research center losing thousands of lab mice as well as precious reagents—a situation that could set some researchers back years.

At New York University’s Smilow Research Center, on the eastern edge of Manhattan, which lost power shortly after Sandy struck on Monday night, hundreds of biological samples were destroyed as freezers thawed and refrigerators warmed. And as animal care facilities in the basement flooded, hundreds of mice and rats were killed—animals that had been painstakingly genetically engineered for use as disease models.

“Animal resource staff was on site continuously to mitigate the damage from the storm, but due to the speed and force of the surge, animal rescue attempts were unsuccessful," NYU officials said in a statement released on Wednesday (October 31). "We are deeply saddened by the loss of these animals' lives and the impact this has on the many years of important work conducted by our researchers.”

Gordon J. Fishell, associate director of the NYU neuroscience institute told The New York Times that his lab alone had lost about 2,500 mice, including 40 different strains. “These animals were the culmination of 10 years of work, and it will take time to replace them,” Fishell told the NYT, which reported a total of some 7,500 more rodents lost from other labs in the Smilow building.

Some mice may be replaceable, especially those shared with collaborators at other institutions. Fishell told Nature that researchers from other universities had already offered to help him replenish his mouse colony. But mice strains and reagents unique to NYU may be lost forever.

Flooding in the East Village area of New York City, also caused by super storm Sandy.Wikimedia, David ShankboneIn the same building that houses Fishell’s lab, cells and tissue samples stored in lab fridges and freezers were destroyed. The generators in the basement were flooded and thus failed to provide backup power after the electricity was lost. "It's so horrible, you don't even want to think about it," Michelle Krogsgaard, a cancer biologist who runs a lab in the Smilow building, told ABC News. "All the work we did, all the time and money, we're going to have to start all over. We could lose everything we've done since I started at NYU 6 years ago.

The Scientist could not reach anyone at the Smilow Research Center, as the facility seems to have gone off the grid. Emails bounced back with a “delivery failed” error message, and phone calls were answered by an automated message stating that phone and email communication would soon be restored.

Other New York City research institutions are also affected. The generators on NYU’s main campus off Washington Square successfully powered up the building housing the lab of Stephen Small after it lost power Monday night, but campus was “otherwise deserted,” according to one of Small’s postdocs.

And though Kyu Rhee’s lab at Weill Cornell Medical College was largely unaffected by the storm, his work was significantly impeded when he was forced to evacuate his home in Bergen County, New Jersey, after a tree fell onto the roof. Once the storm had passed, Rhee and his family had to drive around streets trying to find a place to stay. He is currently moving from hotel to hotel with his wife and two young children, he said, until they find more permanent accommodation.

For now, Rhee is operating his lab “remotely via intermittent Internet access as I can find it in McDonalds or other coffee shops,” he said. This situation “has made impending grant and progress report deadlines considerably more challenging to navigate,” he said, and has “delayed the submission of time-sensitive manuscripts.” It also made it difficult to coordinate interviews with reporters about his new Science paper on the unexpected mechanism of a tuberculosis drug, just released this afternoon.

Furthermore, Sandy’s impact on science wasn’t limited to the Big Apple. Down in Baltimore, for example, scientists formed a human chain to take cages containing lab mice to safety as floodwaters filled the basement of the Koch Cancer Research Center at Johns Hopkins University, according a report in ScienceInsider.

Even the publishing side of scientific research was affected by the storm. Nature Publishing Group, for example, lost power at its New York office, disrupting its typical publication schedule. “Some journal issues have been delayed this week but we expect to get these out next week alongside the normal issue publication schedule,” a spokesperson for Nature told The Scientist.

To help victims of Sandy, scientists or otherwise, you can donate to the Red Cross. Visit www.redcross.org, call 800-Red-Cross or text the word "Redcross" to 90999 to make a $10 donation. Other ways to help are listed here.

Add a Comment

Avatar of: You

You

Processing...
Processing...

Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo

Comments

Avatar of: jgrabowski

jgrabowski

Posts: 1

November 2, 2012

 

As one present when tropical storm Allison caused havoc and devastation for scientists and clinicians across the Texas Medical Center (Houston—UT, Baylor etc), in June 2001, sympathy for the NYC scientists is abundant.

Unfathomable is the litany of tales regarding ill-conceived mechanical plans. These include generators, switching systems and fuel tanks in basements. Indeed at TMC, some institutions neglected to move critical components despite severe flooding in earlier decades. Presumably, as with many disasters, preparation in the aftermath is for the just preceding event, not future events of greater severity. Worth noting is that after Allison, TMC systems were dramatically revamped.

Certainly, it is unconscionable that institutions renown for scientific rigor and advances, spending precious research funds and, by the way, constantly under the eye of the animal rights activists, have not created plans to preclude the problems facing NYC scientists (and clinicians). True, systems may be overwhelmed or fail, but, generators/ switches/ fuel in the basement???

Perhaps The Scientist could mount a campaign and survey, determining the prevalence of mechanical malfeasance in risk prone areas around the country. Might funding be contingent on adequacy? Conjure up a list of the most poorly protected and most prepared institutions in the country. Lists seem to impress these days.

John Grabowski PhD

Professor

Department of Psychiatry

University of Minnesota

Avatar of: Paul Stein

Paul Stein

Posts: 121

November 2, 2012

Since Tropical Storm Allison drowned the animals at the University of Texas at Houston in 2001, one would think that people would have stopped stuffing facilities in risk-filled basements long ago.  

Avatar of: Shengqian

Shengqian

Posts: 5

November 2, 2012

“Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited to all we now know and understand, while imagination embraces the entire world, and all there ever will be to know and understand.”
Avatar of: Roy Niles

Roy Niles

Posts: 58

November 3, 2012

Risk taking (that's required of all of us) and its tradeoffs have never been reduced to the fine art that some here seem to think they would have reduced it to in the place of those in NYC who clearly hadn't.  A professor of psychiatry should at least know better.

These people will sadly learn from their mistakes, just as they had learned, in spite of this sad case, to have avoided numerous others over the years.  And we all must realize that the risks that overtook them in this instance were some doozies.

At least these people didn't die, and if they had, some would have then argued they were nuts for ever staying in NYC at all.

Avatar of: TheScore

TheScore

Posts: 1

November 15, 2012

It is unfathomable that these institutions did not institute appropriate measures to avoid this.  There have been numerous previous instances, including Houston, as someone mentioned.  

 

Even as a scientist, it's tough for me to think of those animals trapped in their cages when the water came.  We need to do more and have more respect...both for the animals and mother nature.    

Avatar of: Cheaptrx

Cheaptrx

Posts: 51

December 17, 2012

I have fun read this blog post. TRX suspesion trainerI want to see

 more about this topic.TRX for saleThank you for publishing this 

quality information.Anyhow, I’m likely to subscribe to your rss as

 well as I wish you make good articles again soon.

http://www.trxforsalex.com/

http://www.trxforsale2012.com/

Follow The Scientist

icon-facebook icon-linkedin icon-twitter icon-vimeo icon-youtube
Advertisement

Stay Connected with The Scientist

  • icon-facebook The Scientist Magazine
  • icon-facebook The Scientist Careers
  • icon-facebook Neuroscience Research Techniques
  • icon-facebook Genetic Research Techniques
  • icon-facebook Cell Culture Techniques
  • icon-facebook Microbiology and Immunology
  • icon-facebook Cancer Research and Technology
  • icon-facebook Stem Cell and Regenerative Science
Advertisement
BioTek
BioTek
Advertisement
NeuroScientistNews
NeuroScientistNews