The Legacy of Kyoto

The Kyoto agreement to reduce global greenhouse gas emissions was flawed, but it provides useful lessons for upcoming climate regulation negotiations.

By | November 29, 2012

Wikimedia, High ContrastInternational climate regulation is about to end. On January 1, 2013, the commitments made by 37 nations to reduce greenhouse gas emissions as part of the Kyoto protocol will expire, leaving the world with the challenge of producing a new agreement.

The 1997 treaty ran into trouble from the start. By the time the protocol came into force in 2005, the United States had pulled out because China and other developing nations had refused to reduce to their emissions until the developed world acted.

The nations that did ratify the pact pledged to reduce emissions from 1990 levels by an average of 4.2 percent between 2008 and 2012. Most met their commitments, but because Kyoto did not set limits for developing countries, total global emissions have surged by 50 percent since 1990, largely driven by massive economic expansion and coal burning in China and other parts of Asia.

“Kyoto had a very limited impact on climate,” Atte Korhola, an environmental-policy researcher at the University of Helsinki, told Nature. “It was too narrow in ambition, its tools were too massively bureaucratic, and it offered too many loopholes.”

Nevertheless, Kyoto does offer some valuable lessons for global leaders preparing to negotiate a new climate treaty in 2015. For example, the carbon cap-and-trade system and carbon taxes developed in Europe, Australia, Japan, China, California, and some parts of Canada could be expanded across the world to help stimulate technological advances that would reduce emissions.

“Kyoto was a grand policy experiment with important lessons we ought to take forward,” Roger Pielke Jr., who studies energy and innovation policy at the University of Colorado Boulder, told Nature. “It had its flaws—no wonder, you rarely get policies right the first time—but the overall architecture is still useful.”

Add a Comment

Avatar of: You

You

Processing...
Processing...

Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo

Popular Now

  1. Antarctica Is Turning Green
  2. How to Tell a Person’s “Brain Age”
  3. Male Fish Borrows Egg to Clone Itself
  4. Life Science Funding Cuts Leaked
    The Nutshell Life Science Funding Cuts Leaked

    According to a document posted online less than a day before the release of the official 2018 budget proposal, the National Institutes of Health could face even deeper cuts than previously suggested by the Trump administration.

AAAS