Bad Stats Plague Neuroscience

A new study blames the unreliable nature of some research in the field on underpowered statistical analyses.

By | April 16, 2013

An image from an fMRI study of brain activity in schizophrenia patientsWIKIMEDIA, PLOS One. 2010 AUG 11;5(8):e12068.Weak statistics are the downfall of many neuroscience studies, according to researchers that analyzed the statistical strategies employed by dozens of published reports in the field. Especially lacking in statistical power are human neuroimaging studies—especially those that use fMRI to infer brain activity—noted the coauthors of the analysis, published in Nature Reviews Neuroscience last week (April 10).

By taking a look at 49 meta-analyses published in 2011, involving a total of 730 neuroscience studies, a team of researchers from the United Kingdom and United States found that about half of the papers had a statistical power below 20 percent. Statistical power is a measure of the probability that a study will detect the presence of a true phenomenon in the samples at hand. High-powered studies can demonstrate even small effects if sample sizes are big enough. Low-powered studies, however, run the risk of either missing genuine phenomena or reporting false positives, usually due to considering too few samples. Research studies typically aim to have a statistical power of at least 80 percent.

Human neuroimaging studies had a median statistical power of just 8 percent, the researchers found.

“This paper should help by revealing exactly how bad things have gotten,” Hal Pashler, a psychologist at the University of California, San Diego, who wasn’t involved with the study, told Wired Science.

Senior author Marcus Munafò, a psychologist at the University of Bristol, United Kingdom, told Wired that such underpowered statistics in neuroscience research may be the result of publishing pressure. ”In many cases, we’re more incentivized to be productive than to be right,” he said.


Add a Comment

Avatar of: You



Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo


Avatar of: agular17


Posts: 5

December 7, 2013

Whats left to say, Okay, we're done, film at eleven.

Popular Now

  1. Inside a Lab Mouse’s High-Fat Diet
  2. Battling the Bulge
    Bio Business Battling the Bulge

    Weight-loss drugs that target newly characterized obesity-related receptors and pathways could finally offer truly effective fat control.

  3. How Gastric Bypass Can Kill Sugar Cravings
  4. Birth of the Skin Microbiome
    Daily News Birth of the Skin Microbiome

    The immune system tolerates the colonization of commensal bacteria on the skin with the aid of regulatory T cells during the first few weeks of life, a mouse study shows.

Life Technologies