Do Crustaceans Feel Pain?

An animal behavior professor argues that crabs and lobsters respond to electrical shocks in a way that suggests discomfort.

By | August 9, 2013

WIKIMEDIA, ARTHROHumans frequently boil or dismember crustaceans while the animals are still alive, assuming they feel no pain. But a Queen’s University Belfast professor of animal behavior argued in a talk he gave this week (August 7) that the arthropods do experience pain, Nature reported.

The speaker, Robert Elwood, based his assertions on a series of experiments in which crabs were subjected to electric shocks. Many have argued that crustaceans do not feel pain, claiming the animals’ responses to stimuli like electric shocks are merely automatic.

In one set of experiments, Elwood and a colleague allowed shore crabs to choose to enter one of two shelters. One shelter delivered electric shocks to the animals, while the other did not. The crabs appeared to learn to avoid the chambers where shocks had been delivered.

In a second set of experiments, the researchers subjected hermit crabs to shocks within their shells. Hermit crabs typically did not leave their shells unless offered a new one, but the animals that had been shocked were more likely to seek new homes.

Elwood argued that these “aversive behaviors” are a sign that crustaceans do experience pain and seek to avoid it.

“Assessing pain is difficult, even within humans,” Elwood said at the meeting, according to Nature. But he added that there was a “clear, long-term motivational change [in these experiments] that is entirely consistent with the idea of pain.”

Add a Comment

Avatar of: You

You

Processing...
Processing...

Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo

Comments

Avatar of: JToeppen

JToeppen

Posts: 37

August 9, 2013

Every living thing must respond appropriately to its environment to survive. Positive and negative reinforcement certainly exist in nature and in labs.

As living creatures ourselves this would seem evident. All living things have some subjective behaviors that work as natural programs allowing them to optimize, reproduce, and flourish. If we choose to believe that "pain" is a higher level response related to intellect alone then we are simply arrogant, indifferent, and egocentric.

Life is consumed by life, and we are omnivores and are well used to that by now. We optimize our own lives by eating living things and this is our nature. However, it is a very good thing if people generally respect all living things and reduce pain and suffering in the world where possible. The rewards for this are most evident to those who practice this approach.

Popular Now

  1. Gut Microbes Linked to Neurodegenerative Disease
  2. Top 10 Innovations 2016
    Features Top 10 Innovations 2016

    This year’s list of winners celebrates both large leaps and small (but important) steps in life science technology.

  3. Opinion: WHO’s Silence on Cannabis
  4. Image of the Day: Parting Ways
    Image of the Day Image of the Day: Parting Ways

    The Allen Institute for Cell Science releases the first public collection of human induced pluripotent stem cells that have been fluorescently tagged using CRISPR.

Rockland