Drivers of Tropical Diversity

Researchers pinpoint rapid speciation, reduced extinction rates as reasons for increased diversity among tropical amphibians.

By | September 10, 2013

Tree frogs evolved in the tropics, but many, like this European tree frog (Hyla arborea), have adapted to temperate regions.SXC.HU, MIHAI TAMASILA

Analyzing climatic data and the evolutionary relationships of nearly 3,000 amphibian species, a pair of researchers has identified the primary causes of the class' species richness in the tropics. A study citing the swift evolution of new species and historically low levels of extinction around the equator, as well as an influx of species from cooler latitudes, was published today (September 10) in the Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. In contrast, the researchers found that amphibian groups in temperate regions exhibited an inverse trend: cooler climates correlated with slower speciation and higher extinction rates, and generally do not attract new species dispersing from the tropics.

“The paper is remarkable in its reach to examine a diverse set of hypotheses for the generation of the latitudinal diversity gradient and to treat these hypotheses synthetically,” Gary Mittelbach, a professor of zoology at Michigan State University’s Kellogg Biological Station who was not involved in the study, told The Scientist in an e-mail. “The authors make a strong case for the importance of high rates of diversification at low latitudes, driven by high speciation and low extinction in topical environments and the opposite pattern in temperate environments,” he added. “This is an important result.”

The question of why biodiversity is highest in the tropics and sparser in temperate zones has fascinated scientists for centuries, predating even Charles Darwin and Alfred Russell Wallace. “The luxuriance and beauty of Tropical Nature is a well-worn theme,” Wallace wrote in the 1878 preface to Tropical Nature, and other essays, a book in which he attempted to document and explain the differences between tropical and temperate regions.

Today, researchers refer to the phenomenon as the latitudinal diversity gradient, which has been documented across taxa, time periods, and geography. Fully understanding global patterns of diversity remains a major research question, but biologists are inching closer.

The present study is a model for the kind of large-scale analyses needed to fully decipher the mechanisms driving diversity patterns. The authors combined existing data sets and new modeling algorithms for their investigation, drawing most significantly from the IUCN Global Amphibian Assessment and an evolutionary tree of amphibians they had developed in 2011. The Amphibian Assessment provided range maps for the world’s known amphibian species, from which the team was able to calculate climatic conditions for each. Amphibians make up one of the most abundant vertebrate groups on land, comprising about 7,000 species of frogs, toads, salamanders, and caecilians. Around 40 percent of those were included in the evolutionary tree used for this study. The authors also took advantage modeling algorithms released within the last few years, which require data from large evolutionary trees to function effectively.

“This is the big data approach to this long-standing question,” said co-author John Wiens, professor of ecology and evolutionary biology at the University of Arizona. Between the large data sets and powerful software, Wiens and his colleague Alex Pyron, an evolutionary biologist at George Washington University, were able to test detailed hypotheses on how speciation, extinction, and dispersal vary between amphibians in temperate and tropical zones.

While the study did not investigate why speciation, extinction, and dispersal differ across latitudes, the authors offered intriguing speculations. One potential explanation for the difference in the rates at which new species evolve within the regions, they noted, could be that “tropical climates foster higher rates of molecular evolution, leading to increased speciation rates.”

Extinction may be higher in temperate latitudes, the authors suggested, because glacial cycles have caused environmental conditions there to fluctuate more quickly, geologically speaking, than in the stable tropics. Amphibian species that couldn’t adapt to the changing climate would go extinct, thus trimming the evolutionary tree. This regular pruning has left ancient, well-adapted families—such as North America’s spadefoot toads and tailed frogs—in temperate regions, while tropical latitudes are full of younger, diversified families.

Lastly is the finding that amphibians often disperse from temperate zones to the tropics, but rarely the other way around. That could be a function of limited resources in cooler climates or simply colder winters that stop amphibian species from “crossing the line of death,” Wiens said.

Scientists are in the process of compiling comprehensive evolutionary trees of many more animal and plant groups, making it likely that large-scale analyses will grow more feasible. Like studies before them, they may not all agree on the mechanisms through which global diversity occurs. But one thing is clear, said Mittelbach: “They all point to the tropics as the engine of biodiversity, both as a cradle for the generation of new species and as a museum for the preservation of diversity.”

R.A. Pyron and J.J. Wiens, “Large-scale phylogenetic analyses reveal the causes of high tropical amphibian diversity,” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, doi: 10.1098/rspb.2013.1622, 2013.

Add a Comment

Avatar of: You



Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo


Avatar of: Salticidologist


Posts: 38

September 11, 2013

This makes good sense.  Now to look at the details, at the level of individual species.  With salticid spiders, there are a number of species that range from temperate into tropical areas, but many more species restricted to either the tropics, or to areas where the soil does not freeze in winter.  Survival in high-latitude regions requires special adaptations (seasonal behavior, shelter construction, movement to warmer locations in the soil, 'antifreeze' in the blood, etc.)  to deal with survival during long periods of inactivity and cold, for example.  It is not a trivial matter to acquire these, and many tropical groups have not crossed this barrier.  Once these survival abilities are acquired, however, it is probably easier to lose them, for a species that has evolved other capabilities that enable it to find a niche in the subtropics or tropics.

Avatar of: Barry@DataSense


Posts: 15

September 11, 2013

I haven't yet read the full paper, but from above report it seems they are still begging the question - they are describing observations rather than explaing them. Is there any evidence that mutation rates (molecular evolution) are higher at low latitudes? The relative stability of the tropical environment over recent geological time must certainly be a factor facilitating species' survival. And species' extensions would certainly be easier from the higher diverse into lesser diverse regions than vice verca.

So, the underlying question is, for those taxonomic group in the tropics where there are more species (and remember that this is not universal for all groups or for all regions), one must question how it is that the higher number of species can be maintained. This is essentially an ecological/zoogeographic question and must involve the energy demands required to maintain a viable population, local extinction/recolonization rates, reciprocal recolonization, migration pathways, biotic corridors, local isolating mechanisms, and predictability (certainty) of local environmental conditions.

And while overall we tend to think that the lower lattudes have been environmentally more stable over time, there has been considerable altitudinal variability with climate changes and there have been many, repeated, isolating situations in the tropics as habitats have moved up and down altitudinally.

Popular Now

  1. Unstructured Proteins Help Tardigrades Survive Desiccation
  2. What Budget Cuts Might Mean for US Science
    News Analysis What Budget Cuts Might Mean for US Science

    A look at the historical effects of downsized research funding suggests that the Trump administration’s proposed budget could hit early-career scientists the hardest.  

  3. Opinion: On “The Impact Factor Fallacy”
  4. Inflammation Drives Gut Bacteria Evolution
Business Birmingham