STEM Students Benefit from Active Learning

Classroom techniques that require student involvement boost grades more than traditional classroom lectures, an analysis finds.

By | May 14, 2014

WIKIMEDIA, XBXG32000So-called “active” learning may help students fare better grade-wise than classic lectures, according to a meta-analysis of 225 studies published this week (May 12) in PNAS. A team led by Scott Freeman of the University of Washington found that undergraduate students in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) courses  with a lecture-only format were one-and-a-half times more likely to fail than were those in classes involving some form of active learning.

Active learning, while not strictly defined, can include using clickers to gauge student responses, asking students to split into active group workshops, and calling on individuals randomly. Using an active learning approach improved students’ grades by about 6 percent, on average, and could even bump an individual student a full letter grade higher.

“This is a really important article—the impression I get is that it’s almost unethical to be lecturing if you have this data,” Eric Mazur, a physicist at Harvard University who uses active learning techniques, but was not involved in the work, told ScienceNOW. “It’s good to see such a cohesive picture emerge from their meta-analysis—an abundance of proof that lecturing is outmoded, outdated, and inefficient.” 

Others, like former sociology professor Frank Furedi, criticized the study’s approach of splitting classes into lecture-only and those that employed any type of active learning, who called it a “false polarization.”

“Only an idiot would rely entirely on lectures—that hasn’t happened for 200 years,” he told Inside Higher Ed. “The art of teaching is getting that balance between giving the lectures creatively to impart information and organizing more intensive interactive discussions with students, in different formats.”

Add a Comment

Avatar of: You



Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo


Avatar of: Mounthell


Posts: 44

May 14, 2014

How can this come as a surprise?

Avatar of: mpoultry


Posts: 2

May 14, 2014



I would like to know not percentage changes in grades -- a somewhat fanciful measure of performance and retention, but performance on content-based standardized STEM exams, like the MCAT or the GRE area-specific exams.  Otherwise, it becomes a story about archers painting bulls-eyes around their arrows wherever they fall.


Popular Now

  1. Monsanto Buys Rights to CRISPR
    The Nutshell Monsanto Buys Rights to CRISPR

    The US agribusiness secures a global, nonexclusive licensing agreement from the Broad Institute to use the gene-editing technology for agricultural applications.

  2. Does Productivity Diminish Research Quality?
  3. How Plants Evolved Different Ways to Make Caffeine
  4. ESP on Trial
    Foundations ESP on Trial

    In the 1930s, parapsychologist Joseph Banks Rhine aimed to use scientific methods to confirm the existence of extrasensory perception, but faced criticisms of dubious analyses and irreproducible results.