Soda, with a Side of Chagas

How did a deadly disease creep into a popular Brazilian beverage?


Jack Woodall
The price of freedom from disease is eternal vigilance.

On February 13, 2005, a man living in a little town near Navegantes in southern Brazil, took his family for a Sunday outing on interstate highway BR-101, which runs alongside an exceptionally beautiful stretch of beaches in Santa Catarina state. In need of refreshment, they drank sugarcane juice from a kiosk by the side of the road. The cane was fresh, machine-crushed in front of them over a block of ice in a jug - just the thing to cool them off in the heat of the southern summer. A short time later they all came down with fever, swollen lymph nodes, malaise, and enlarged livers and spleens. In a few days, four of them were dead.

After all common infections had been excluded, doctors came up with the diagnosis of Chagas' disease, also known as American trypanosomiasis. It kills around 10% of those infected, and one in four survivors may develop a chronic infection that eventually causes serious heart damage. However, the disease had never been reported in the area where the family fell ill, being typical of bug-ridden thatched houses in rural areas of Brazil and much of Latin America. Here, triatomid insects, tough little bloodsuckers about an inch long, live in the thatched roofs and wall crevices of adobe houses. One such dwelling may harbor thousands of the little brutes, and an unfortunate soul sleeping there may get more than 25 bites per night. The family from outside Navegantes, however, lived in a bug-free masonry house in town.

Up till then, the only known way for town-dwellers to catch the disease was from a blood transfusion or organ transplant from an infected rural donor, but no one in the family had had anything like that. Grasping at straws, epidemiologists checked out the cane juice kiosk. They found cut sugarcane stacked in the open, and the smoking gun: an infected bug that had evidently been brought in from the cane field where it had fed on an infected wild animal, probably an opossum. The high death rate in these cases was attributed to the much larger dose of parasites ingested than that which enters through a bite.

By mid-March, 2005, there were 25 confirmed cases, six deaths, and possibly more than 50,000 exposures to cane juice - including among international travelers - along the beaches of Santa Catarina. The authorities closed down all the kiosks along the relevant stretch of highway BR-101, banned blood donations from anyone who had drunk cane juice from them within the previous two months, and recommended that anyone who had done so, and developed a fever and similar symptoms, consult a physician.

Since then, infections have been traced to other contaminated popular juices, such as those squeezed from the fruits of the tropical açaí and babassu palms. Açaí is a popular, refreshing drink from the juice of the deep purple berries that sprout from a short, slender, multi-stemmed jungle palm. Nowadays, açaí causes an average of one case of Chagas' disease every four days in the Brazilian Amazon. In recent years, the pulp and juice has been exported to southern Brazil, and also to the United States and England, where it can be found in shops frequented by Brazilians and health food fans.

Only last year, after a long and hard-fought campaign of spraying bug-infested houses with residual pyrethroid insecticides, the Pan American Health Organization certified Brazil as free of the domestically transmitted disease. But the disease remains in wildlife and the bugs that feed on them, so now the risk is from bugs accidentally ground up in regional beverages. This is another example of what happens almost every time we think we have controlled a disease - a rump remnant surfaces to bedevil us. Examples include vaccine-associated polio, and extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis (XDR TB).

To coin a paraphrase, the price of freedom from disease is eternal vigilance, which, in this particular instance, takes the form of ensuring that cane and fruit are washed free of bugs before crushing. The drink will be a lot more refreshing.

Jack Woodall is former director of the Nucleus for the Investigation of Emerging Infectious Diseases in the Institute of Medical Biochemistry at Brazil's Federal University of Rio de Janeiro.



Advertisement


 

Rate this article

Rating: 5.00/5 (2 votes )





Same thing now in Caracas, Venezuela
by Jack Woodall

[Comment posted 2007-12-26 13:26:33]
In December 2007 there was outbreak of acute Chagas disease in Andres Bello Municipal School, Chacao, metropolitan Caracas. At least 98 people have been confirmed with the acute disease. While the infection may be restricted to this school, as a preventive measure, the Ministry of Health has declared a national sanitary alert. Since there are no triatomid bugs in the urban school buildings or environment, suspicion has fallen on the fruit juice consumed there. It is prepared fresh every day in a village which is infested with the bugs. Source: http://www.el-nacional.com [in Spanish; for English translation see www.promedmail.org for 26 Dec 2007].



what happens to the tryp when it is processed?
by Dan Miller

[Comment posted 2007-11-10 00:18:18]
The mention about the export of the juice to other countries brings into question whether the tryp would survive the process necessary to sterilize the juice when it is canned. I wouldn't think that it could survive.



Sugar Cane Juice and Chagas Connection
by Dr.Raam Shanthi

[Comment posted 2007-11-08 21:04:23]
What a shocking story! It is too bad we have to learn this from fatal accidents. Emphasis is on basics of hygiene- always wash what you eat; watch what you eat before you put anything in your mouth- our grandmas advice sounds good. More importantly, bringing basics of discoveries such as these to the non-scientist lay public is crucial. Every hut dweller in Brazil and other countries where the bug is found should be aware of this bug, learn to identify it and be aware of what its bite can do to them; where it lays it s eggs, what it feeds on, where it hides and how to prevent it from being a menace. Dr.Richard Gallagher's article on framing science gains significance once again!



To Mike
by Luis

[Comment posted 2007-11-08 08:46:45]
I'm from S ̄o Paulo and all I have to say is: don't worry so much. Capirinha is 100% sure to be safe. Pinga has about 40-50% alchohol, lots of sugar and lemon juice. About sugar cane juice, it's unlike to carry any risk, especially since the 2005 deaths. The best way to proceed is to go to a "Feira Livre" where you can actually watch de canes that are about to be used in making the juice.



Question........
by Mike

[Comment posted 2007-11-07 16:48:43]
I'm about to travel to Sao Paulo and Florianopolis, should I avoid drinking sugar cane or juice-based drinks while there? More specifically, should I avoid drinking Caipirinhas? Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks.