News:
FDA: Clone it, then eat it
Posted by Ivan Oransky
[Entry posted at 28th December 2006 09:08 PM GMT]
Comment on this news story   
Good news for those of you who have been keeping a cloned T-bone in your freezer waiting to see if it's safe to eat: In an announcement that surprised no one, the FDA today gingerly said that it's OK to eat cloned cows and pigs. Cloned milk and meat more than likely won't even need a label.

The timing of the announcement suggests that the FDA wanted as little scrutiny of the report as possible ?- the week before Christmas and New Year's is, as the Raelians figured out in 2002, the time to announce news about cloning ?- but the response was predictable. In advance of the announcement, the American Anti-Vivisection Society said it was opposed to all animal cloning because of high failure rates, while the Competitive Enterprise Institute -- a 'non-partisan public policy group dedicated to the principles of free enterprise and limited government' that has challenged calls for anti-global warming efforts -- applauded the decision.

As usual, the truth lies somewhere between the descriptions by self-described non-partisans who look only at the data that supports their causes. The FDA seems to be following the evidence for potential harm to human health pretty carefully here ? that is to say, there doesn?t seem to be any. Whether or not people will actually want to eat cloned animals, however, remains to be seen. A Pew Initiative for Food and Biotechnology poll earlier this month had 64% of Americans saying they were uncomfortable with animal cloning , and 46% saying they were 'strongly uncomfortable,' although the poll didn't ask specifically about eating Dolly's cloned cousins. (The FDA reserved judgment on whether cloned sheep would be safe to eat, saying the evidence wasn't definitive yet.) In any case, cloned animals are unlikely to make it into the food chain in large numbers anytime soon. Cloned breeders, however, might become more popular.

Let's see if McDonald's halves the price of its double cheeseburger .

For FREE access to this news story and more, you must register.

Not yet registered? Get free access
 

The article you are attempting to read is only available to registered users of The Scientist. Registration is FREE and only takes a few seconds.

 
 

Email

Password

> Forgot Password?
> FAQ
> Subscribe

 
Not yet registered? Get free access
 

Create your MyScientist account and access all of The Scientist's free content, tools and life science email newsletters, including:

 

> The current month’s print issue

> Daily & Bi-weekly e-mail newsletters

> Newsblogs with breaking headlines

> The Scientist Community

> Exclusive web extras

> The Scientist Careers

 

Premium content from The Scientist Archive, a comprehensive resource of over 22 years of past life science coverage, is available only by subscription. Subscribe today and get unlimited access

 

 
LATEST NEWS