The Scientist : NewsBlog Print: Hwang heads back to the bench
The Scientist: NewsBlog:
Hwang heads back to the bench
Posted by Stephen Pincock
[Entry posted at 28th June 2006 02:32 PM GMT]

The remarkable tale of disgraced South Korean researcher Hwang Woo-suk has taken another startling twist. It turns out he?s planning to open his own lab in Seoul next month, using private money to do conduct animal cloning and perhaps human embryonic stem cell research.

Nobody will need reminding of Hwang?s high-profile woes. Once a national hero, he was forced to leave his post at Seoul National University late last year amid accusations of ethical lapses and fabricated data. He has also been charged with fraud and embezzlement.

Hwang?s lawyer has painted the latest move in a humble light. "It is Dr. Hwang's belief that the only way to reclaim his honor and repay the people who have helped him, and win their forgiveness, is to produce accomplishments in research," he told Reuters over the telephone. The plan is to hire a lot of the scientists who had previously worked with Hwang, he said.

The big question, of course, is whether Hwang will be able to convince any journal in the world to publish future work. "There will be a lot of people in the scientific world who will vilify him for this," said Stephen Minger, a stem cell researcher from King?s College London, "but there?s a lot of expertise in his lab that I would hate to see wasted."

"I?m sure he will put himself up for the most stringent scrutiny that any scientist has," Minger added, "and everyone does deserve a second chance." Either way, it seems safe to say that journal editors will be looking at any future work Hwang produces rather more closely than they have in the past.




 

Rate this article

Rating: 3.40/5 (5 votes )





Stem cell stories
by Ivan Oransky

[Comment posted 2007-06-22 13:27:39]

Dr. McGrath

Thanks for your comment on our website. I wanted to draw your attention to a few stories we've done on the company to which you refer:

http://www.the-scientist.com/news/display/53194/
http://www.the-scientist.com/blog/display/53186/

We have also done a lot of stories on Hwang and other stem cell cases, as our archives will show.





Stem Cell Fraud
by Vince McGrath

[Comment posted 2007-06-22 13:08:40]

I have become quite interested in SC fraud cases and all the deceptive advertisement, truth claims, and corporate sponsorships tied to the research.
I would appreciate internet sites, journals, and other investigative sources which are tracking and exposing such practices. I received a CD from a StemEnhance company with a sales pitch for those who would like to sell the product. The promises were cautiously stated but still embedded in the jargon. I use Judson's The Great Betrayal in my doctoral level classes at my institution.





Comment on this blog