|
The Scientist: NewsBlog:
Public choosing science on PBS
Posted by Alison McCook [Entry posted at 8th January 2007 02:57 PM GMT]
Rate this article
Return to Top comment: Science education is very important, especially today by B. Morgan [Comment posted 2007-02-04 15:21:26] Dr. Vinod Nikhra, science is not entertainment, OK. But surely even you can acknowledge what scientists like Carl Sagan did for the rest of us non-scientists. He brought a very complex science that, until he came along, was closed to most of us. He brought it down to earth for the rest of us to wonder about. He made it understandable and accessible.
And according to you, this is a bad thing? I hope you're not a teacher. Return to Top comment: Education and Entertainment Go Hand-in-Hand by Charles Osolin, Livermore, CA [Comment posted 2007-01-25 20:00:52] Dr. Nikhra's attitude toward communicating science to the public is all too typical of many scientists, and is an important reason for the appaling level of scientific illiteracy in the supposedly "developed" nations of the world. The problems caused by occasional news media misinterpretation or misreporting of research are far outweighed by the problems of scientific illiteracy and neo-luddism. Unless science is presented in public forums as exciting, entertaining, and -- most important -- relevant to the life of average citizens, those citizens will have no reason to pay attention to or educate themselves about scientific issues and advancements. Many, if not most, people will continue to hold irrational -- or at best, non-commital -- attitudes toward such issues as stem-cell research, global warming, and bioengineering, not to mention such basic research areas as high-energy physics, fusion and astrophysics. PBS does a great service to both science and the public interest by working to make science entertaining, interesting and relevant. The best way to do that is to discern the interests of the viewing audience and develop thoughtful programming, with the right amount of scientific input, that matches those interests. Return to Top comment: Science is no entertainment! by Dr. Vinod Nikhra, New Delhi, India [Comment posted 2007-01-23 13:11:47] The science is no entertainment, period. I have seen over the years newspapers, popular magazines, tv shows and other media presenting things often on irrational basis. Programs are presented depending on their e-value. This is no science. It will not help in developing a scientific attitude, it will not help educating public in scientific advancements either. Briefly, the presentations should be in a scientific manner.
Editors' choice is a good thing. Asking people to know what they want is like chosing to see one from a movie list. This will lead to lopsided knowledge. May prove often harmful than good. Comment on this blog |