Beware of Striking Medical Studies

A large-scale statistical analysis shows that medical studies revealing “very large effects” seldom stand up when other researchers try to replicate them.

By | October 25, 2012

Wikimedia, BmramonClinical trials that find very large effects for medical treatments tend not to hold up under further scrutiny, according a study published this week (October 24) in the Journal of the American Medical Association. The authors say the findings should be a reminder to be cautious about exciting early studies.

Analyzing data from 230,000 clinical trials across various disciplines, a team led by Stanford University epidemiologist John Ioannadis found that researchers rarely succeed in replicating study results that claimed a “very large effect.” “The effects largely go away; they become much smaller,” Ioannidis told the Los Angeles Times. “It's likely that most interventions that are effective have modest effects.”

The analysis also revealed that studies reporting outstanding results tended to have used fewer than 100 subjects, so the effects are more likely to be influenced by chance. Moreover, “very large effect” studies usually measure intermediate effects, such as whether statins reduce LDL cholesterol in the blood, rather than more meaningful outcomes like the incidence of disease or death.

The authors suggest that the results should reiterate to patients, physicians, and policymakers that drugs or devices that get glowing reports in small, early-stage trials should be treated with caution—rather than rushed through for approval.

Gordon Guyatt, a clinical epidemiologist at McMaster University in Hamilton, Canada, who was not involved in the study, agreed. People tend to “get excited, and misguidedly so” by these “very large effect” results, he told the LA Times.

(Hat tip to GenomeWeb)

Add a Comment

Avatar of: You



Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo

Popular Now

  1. That Other CRISPR Patent Dispute
    Daily News That Other CRISPR Patent Dispute

    The Broad Institute and Rockefeller University disagree over which scientists should be named as inventors on certain patents involving the gene-editing technology.

  2. How Gaining and Losing Weight Affects the Body
    Daily News How Gaining and Losing Weight Affects the Body

    Millions of measurements from 23 people who consumed extra calories every day for a month reveal changes in proteins, metabolites, and gut microbiota that accompany shifts in body mass.

  3. Neurons Use Virus-Like Proteins to Transmit Information
  4. DOE-Sponsored Oak Ridge National Laboratory to Cut 100 More Jobs