Doubts Surface About Antarctic Life

Researchers contend that contamination is behind recent suggestions that Antarctica’s largest subglacial lake harbors complex life such as crustaceans and fish.

By | July 11, 2013


NASA, JIM YUNGELBiologists studying ice core samples near the surface of Antarctica’s Lake Vostok—considered by many to be one of the world’s harshest environments—recently reported finding microbial evidence that points to the presence of mollusks, crustaceans, annelid worms, and fish. The extraordinary findings have proven too extraordinary for some researchers, who have publicly criticized the work in the days since it was published online last Wednesday (July 3) in PLOS ONE.

Sergey Bulat, a Lake Vostok expert at the Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute in Gatchina, Russia, told Nature that the samples analyzed by Scott Rogers, a biologist at Bowling Green State University, and his team are likely heavily contaminated with microbes from the outside the lake.

“Their analysis is very questionable,” Bulat, whose discovery of bacteria in Lake Vostok in March has also been criticized for possible contamination, told Nature. “It appears to me they have neither run proper controls nor looked at contamination databases to subtract from their results the respective levels of microbial contamination you would expect.”

Writing in their PLOS ONE paper, Rogers’ team acknowledged the possibility of some contamination. But they contend that it is unlikely that the sheer volume of microbes they found could have been the result of contamination. Rogers also defended his team’s use of proper controls to Nature. “We decontaminated our samples in rigorous ways,” he said. “And after the sequencing, we subtracted the level of contamination that we found in our controls.”

Brent Christner, a microbiologist at Louisiana State University, told Nature that he thinks conditions in Lake Vostok are “too extreme to support anything more complex than a nematode.” He added, “It will require extraordinary evidence before I entertain the idea of fish, arthropods, and sea anemones inhabiting it.”

University of California, Santa Cruz, glaciologist Slawek Tulaczyk views Rogers’ discovery as provocative, but is keeping an open mind. “I am confident that the reviewers and editors considered the integrity of samples and procedures while making their decision regarding acceptance of this paper,” he told The Scientist.  

“I see this hypothesis as a thrilling challenge for the rest of us to seek further observations that will verify if only microbes can live in subglacial lakes,” Tulaczyk added. “This speculation is not any more audacious than expecting to find life on other planetary bodies in our solar system.”

Add a Comment

Avatar of: You



Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo

Popular Now

  1. 2017 Top 10 Innovations
    Features 2017 Top 10 Innovations

    From single-cell analysis to whole-genome sequencing, this year’s best new products shine on many levels.

  2. Thousands of Mutations Accumulate in the Human Brain Over a Lifetime
  3. Antiviral Immunotherapy Comes of Age
    News Analysis Antiviral Immunotherapy Comes of Age

    T-cell therapies are not just for cancer. Researchers are also advancing immunotherapy methods to protect bone marrow transplant patients from viral infections. 

  4. The Rising Research Profile of 23andMe
    News Analysis The Rising Research Profile of 23andMe

    An exploration of the genetics of earlobe attachment is just the latest collaborative research project to come out of the personal genetic testing company.