Male Lineage Not Younger Than Females

Two genomic studies place the divergence of men from their most recent common ancestor nearer in time to that of women, though the field is far from a consensus.

By | August 2, 2013

WIKIMEDIA, PLOCIAMMitochondrial Eve—the most recent common ancestor of women, estimated to be 190,000 to 200,000 years old—may not have been much older than ancient “Adam.” According to a pair of papers published in Science yesterday (August 1), the most recent common ancestor of men is now calculated to have lived between 120,000 to 200,000 years ago.

Previous estimates suggested the most recent common male ancestor lived just 50,000 to 60,000 years ago, creating a discrepancy between the divergence of men and women from their most recent common ancestors. But, analyzing the Y chromosome sequences of 69 men from nine populations across the globe, scientists from Stanford University and their colleagues have found that the most recent common patrilineal ancestor did not live much more recently than its matrilineal counterpart. Similarly, by studying the genomes of 1,204 Sardinian men with a focus on the Y chromosome, a team led by investigators at the Università di Sassari in Italy calculated a putative age for the most recent common male ancestor that is consistent with previous estimates of the female ancestor based on mitochondrial DNA.

While it is unlikely that Mitochondrial Eve and Y Chromosome Adam lived side by side, “now it seems that a population giving rise to the strictly maternal and strictly paternal portions of our genomes could have produced individuals who found each other in the same space and time,” the University of Hawaii at Manoa’s Rebecca Cann, professor of cell and molecular biology, wrote in a commentary accompanying the papers.

Stanford’s David Poznik, a PhD student in Carlos Bustamante’s lab, told that he and his colleagues were able to better fill in the human family tree largely because of advances in sequencing technologies. “Essentially, we’ve constructed a family tree for the Y chromosome,” Poznik said. “Prior to high-throughput sequencing, the tree was based on just a few hundred variants. Although these variants had revealed the main topology, we couldn’t say much about the length of any branch—the number of variants shared by all of its descendants.”

Still, researchers in this field are far from reaching a consensus on the ages of Mitochondrial Eve and Y Chromosome Adam. Age estimates based on data reported in both Science studies contradict an approximation published by Michael Hammer and his colleagues in March, which traced the most recent common ancestor of the Y chromosome back some 338,000 years, making it much older than that of mitochondrial DNA.

Chronological discrepancies aside, the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute’s Chris Tyler-Smith said that sequencing genomes has bettered researchers’ understanding of evolution. “It’s great to see large-scale sequencing being applied to the Y chromosome,” Tyler-Smith told Popular Science. “I think this is the future of Y chromosome study.”

Add a Comment

Avatar of: You



Sign In with your LabX Media Group Passport to leave a comment

Not a member? Register Now!

LabX Media Group Passport Logo


Avatar of: Edalessio


Posts: 1

August 23, 2013

The origin of discrepancies are mainly in the calibration of mutation rate. One article uses american population and the other te sardinia island conquer. But both trust on archaelogicl data and that has a considerable margin of error.

Popular Now

  1. Secret Eugenics Conference Uncovered at University College London
  2. Like Humans, Walruses and Bats Cuddle Infants on Their Left Sides
  3. How Do Infant Immune Systems Learn to Tolerate Gut Bacteria?
  4. Scientists Continue to Use Outdated Methods