The nationwide experiment will initially include around 100,000 volunteers.
Fetal specimens collected by commercial whalers offer insights into how whales may have evolved their specialized hearing organs.
September 1, 2015|
MAYA YAMATOFor more than a year, Smithsonian Institute postdoc Maya Yamato spent her days driving whale fetuses between a storage facility outside of Washington, D.C., and the National Museum of Natural History, where she delicately transferred the irreplaceable specimens—some small enough to fit in her hand, others as long as she was tall—into a CT scanner. “The specimens have been cared for by the Smithsonian’s staff for decades, but it only takes a second to mess them up,” says Yamato in an email.
One by one, Yamato and paleobiologist Nicholas Pyenson, curator of fossil marine mammals at the museum, scanned 56 skeletal or ethanol-preserved whale fetuses at various stages of development to understand how underwater mammals—in particular, filter-feeding baleen whales, or mysticetes—developed their specialized systems of hearing.
“We know they sing,” says Pyenson. “But we really don’t know the anatomical basis by which they hear.” He says that although researchers have characterized the hearing adaptations acquired as whales’ tetrapod ancestors made their transition from land to sea, little is known about the natural history and fetal development of modern marine mammals, and much of what is known comes from stranded animals. “Whales are big, and they don’t exactly lend themselves abundantly to these kinds of investigations. So this is where natural history collections become really important.”
Pyenson and Yamato had access to 32 mysticetes and 24 odontocetes, or toothed whales, representing 15 species, most of which were collected by commercial whalers during the first half of the 20th century, though some came from bycatch or pregnant stranded whales. “It would be very difficult to obtain specimens like this now, partly because of the decline in whale populations as a result of whaling,” says Yamato.
While impressive, the collection could have been much larger, given the millions of whales killed by the commercial whaling industry worldwide, Pyenson says; however, penalties associated with culling pregnant or lactating females likely deterred many whalers from turning in fetuses discovered during harvesting aboard whaling ships. “In many cases, those fetuses were just returned to the sea,” he says.
From the CT scans, Pyenson and Yamato were able to glean detailed physiological information without damaging the rare specimens. As a result, they have published the first in situ depiction of the development of a fatty structure called the acoustic funnel, which is found only in whale ears (PLOS ONE, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0118582, 2015). They found that the funnel points forward in toothed whales, such as dolphins and sperm whales, which need to hear at high frequencies and echolocate. The funnel in baleen whales, which hear at much lower frequencies and use deep infrasound to communicate, shifts sideways as they develop. “That goes along with our understanding of the evolution of the head in baleen whales,” says Annalisa Berta, an evolutionary biologist at San Diego State University who was not involved in the study. The funnel’s orientation, she says, may have evolved to allow the baleen whale jaw to rotate to a position more favorable for bulk feeding.
Pyenson plans to use the still-intact specimens and the CT scans to describe the ontogeny of other sensory organs as well. “We have such a great wealth of material. There are a lot of great discoveries to be made.”