A recent toast to James Watson highlights a tolerance for bigotry many want excised from the scientific community.
Ultrasound-stimulated microbubbles enable gene delivery to fix fractures.
September 1, 2017|
© GEORGE RETSECK
Repairing limbs after serious injuries can be a challenge for orthopedic surgeons. If the loss of bone is too great, regrowth is impossible. Smaller fractures can also be problematic if bone growth is insufficient because of the advanced age or poor health of the patient.
The gold standard for treating such nonhealing fractures is autologous bone grafts—where a segment of healthy bone (normally harvested from the patient’s pelvis) is used to bridge the wound. But depending on the extent of the damage or the patient’s health, this option is not always feasible. So in recent years, some doctors have begun to administer bone morphogenetic protein (BMP), which is incorporated into a bone implant to boost healing.
This strategy, too, has its pitfalls. “There are significant side effects,” including bone resorption and bone formation in soft tissues, says skeletal regeneration researcher Dan Gazit of Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles, possibly because BMP is given in large doses. Rather than administer the protein itself, then, perhaps physicians could deliver the underlying gene to cells, providing more-physiological levels of BMP at the site of injury, and less elsewhere in the body.
The viral vectors used to deliver such gene therapies have raised their own safety concerns, however. To overcome this obstacle, Gazit and colleagues employed a delivery mechanism called sonoporation—in which ultrasound is used to induce the oscillation of lipid-shelled, gas-filled microbubbles, causing them to punch tiny, reparable holes in cells through which the DNA can enter.
The researchers also employed a strategy to ensure the DNA was targeted to endogenous mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs), which are proficient at producing BMP. In the fractured tibias of pigs, the team inserted collagen scaffolds, known to attract MSCs, then waited two weeks (for maximal MSC recruitment) before injecting a mix of BMP-encoding DNA and microbubbles at the site of the fracture and applying a pulse of ultrasound. Eight weeks after a single dose of the gene therapy, the pigs’ fractures were mended, while those of control animals were not.
“[Gazit] has now got the proof of principle he needs,” says Mayo Clinic orthopedics researcher Christopher Evans, who was not involved in the study. “That’s really exciting.” (Sci Transl Med, 9: eaal3128, 2017)
|TECHNIQUE||HOW IT WORKS||CLINICAL USE||COMPLICATIONS||BONE FORMING POTENTIAL|
Autologous bone graft
Healthy bone is excised from the patient’s pelvis and inserted into the fracture site to encourage bone growth.
Yes, well established
Patients often have pain at the site of the healthy bone excision.
Very good; limited only by graft-size feasibility
|Sonoporation-driven BMP gene therapy||Plasmid DNA encoding BMP is injected at the fracture site together with lipid-encased microbubbles. Ultrasound causes the microbubbles to oscillate and create micropores in cell membranes. DNA enters the cells and BMP is produced.||
No. It works in a large animal model, but safety testing is required for medical translation.
||The method works at least as well as an autologous bone graft in animals, and possibly better as it is not limited by graft size.|