The prominent researcher has been put on administrative leave pending an investigation into unspecified allegations.
Three studies—one of mice and two of human genetics—describe the role of two proteins, adenylyl cyclase and melanocortin 4 receptor, in the development of obesity and diabetes.
January 8, 2018|
YI WANG, PHD, FROM THE VAISSE LABMost mammalian cells have a primary cilium, an antenna-like, immobile surface projection that senses the surrounding environment. Researchers report in Nature Genetics today (January 8) that proteins localized to the cilia of neurons in the hypothalamus control food intake in mice. Furthermore, two human genetics studies published in Nature Genetics today tie variants of a neuronal ciliary gene, adenylyl cyclase 3 (ADCY3), identified in people from Pakistan, Greenland, and the United States, to an increased risk of obesity and diabetes.
“This [mouse] paper contributes nicely to a consensus that cilia are important in the brain for energy homeostasis and feeding behaviors,” says Nick Berbari, a biologist at Indiana University–Purdue University Indianapolis who did not participate in the study. “It’s interesting to think about how cilia function could be important for the general population, [not] just in rare instances of ciliopathies,” he adds.
Ciliopathies—rare diseases caused by mutations in genes that affect the primary cilia—can produce a variety of symptoms, including extra fingers or toes, retinal degeneration, and obesity, coauthor Christian Vaisse, a geneticist at the University of California, San Francisco, tells The Scientist. “Relatively recently, it was found that the obesity in ciliopathies was linked to a role of the primary cilium in neurons because the genetic removal of primary cilia from all neurons in an adult mouse leads to obesity,” he explains.
Mutations in the gene that codes for melanocortin 4 receptor (MC4R)—a G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR) involved in the signaling pathway that regulates food intake—are among the most common genetic causes of severe obesity. Vaisse and colleagues found that MC4R is enriched in primary cilia in some neurons in the mouse hypothalamus, but that two genetic mutations in MC4R that have been linked to obesity in people prevent that accumulation.
This study gives us further important molecular insight into the role of primary cilia. It’s an exciting finding linking melanocortin 4 receptor with cilia and obesity.—Kirk Mykytyn,
Ohio State University
“What we found here is that what seems to link ciliopathies and body weight regulation is that the melanocortin 4 receptor itself, which is this receptor in which mutation causes severe obesity in humans, is actually located at the primary cilium of those neurons in which it is expressed,” says Vaisse.
The authors also determined that MC4R co-localizes at primary cilia with ADCY3, the protein whose gene was linked with obesity among humans in the other two studies. Because it had been shown before that losing ADCY3 can lead to obesity in mice, Vaisse and colleagues then blocked adenylyl cyclase specifically in the cilia of neurons that contain MC4R. Treated mice ate more food and gained more weight than control mice. Therefore, disrupting MC4R localization to the cilia or ADCY3 signaling in the cilia can lead to obesity, solidifying the role of primary cilia in neuronal regulation of food intake and energy balance.
“This study gives us further important molecular insight into the role of primary cilia. It’s an exciting finding linking melanocortin 4 receptor with cilia and obesity,” says Ohio State University biologist Kirk Mykytyn, who was not involved in the research. “The immediate follow-up question is whether there’s actually signaling of the receptor within the cilium, but that is technically challenging to address,” he adds.
A “bigger picture [question] would be: what other behaviors can these cilia on neurons influence?” says Berbari. Because cilia are found on neurons throughout the brain, they likely impact reward networks, learning and memory, and emotional states, among others, he explains.
A question that Vaisse’s group will focus on going forward is how other genes that have been found to predispose humans to obesity could function in the primary cilium. “One of the reasons we can’t find drugs that work in most patients is that we don’t yet really understand the biology of the system well enough, and, more precisely, what happens downstream of MC4R signaling at the primary cilia,” he says. “And so once we understand this better, we might actually go find drugs that act more downstream of primary cilia signaling in MC4R neurons and that may help a larger proportion of the patients that have genetic defects in this pathway.”
N. Grarup et al., “Loss-of-function variants in ADCY3 increase risk of obesity and type 2 diabetes,” Nature Genetics, doi:10.1038/s41588-017-0022-7, 2018.
S. Saeed et al., “Loss-of-function mutations in ADCY3 cause monogenic severe obesity,” Nature Genetics, doi:10.1038/s41588-017-0023-6, 2018.
J.E. Siljee et al., “Subcellular localization of MC4R with ADCY3 at neuronal primary cilia underlies a common pathway for genetic predisposition to obesity,” Nature Genetics, doi:10.1038/s41588-017-0020-9, 2018.
January 9, 2018
Awesome work. What a ehad scratcher. ...Per
"we don’t yet really understand the biology of the system well enough"
...Well, get on with it.
February 22, 2018
I saw an article elsewhere regarding cilia where the claim was made that the cilia's behavior was due to genetics. Then the aricle admitted they used a metabolic process to induce the genetic response.
What was done here in this research? The article says "Vaisse and colleagues then blocked adenylyl cyclase specifically in the cilia of neurons that contain MC4R." How did they block it? If you're interfering with a metabolic process, it is NOT a genetic condition!
Wikipedia has this to say about adenylyl cyclase, "All classes of adenylyl cyclases catalyse the conversion of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) to 3',5'-cyclic AMP (cAMP) and pyrophosphate. Magnesium ions are generally required and appears to be closely involved in the enzymatic mechanism."
ATP is part of the metabolism. It is not a genetic event. Note also that for ATP to be active it needs Mg. Where does the Mg come from? Through the Mag cell channel.
What would stop this POSITIVELY CHARGED electric light switch (Mg is an ELECTRO LIGHT so to speak) FROM COUPLING with the ATP?
How about the POSITIVE IONS we absorb through our skin such as from cell phones. They would repel the Mg.
Does any of that sound like genetics to you? If so, you are now declaring the use of cell phones to be a genetic condition.
It's not a coincidence that rampant obesity and cell phone use are occurring at the same time. The same is true with Alzheimer's disease. Age adjusted deaths were up 55% between 1998 and 2013. The ions from the phones are screwing up the cilia and the cell channels.
The cilia in the brain develop amyloid plaque in the ventriciles where the known cilia are located. It is at that location where Alzheimer's begins.
The plaque causes stagnation of the cerbrospinal fluid and pressure in the brain occurs. It was reported just last week that the brains of Alzheimer's patients develop leakage in the blood brain barrier. Of course they do. That's what increased pressure does. Just like how a blood vessel can crack from high blood pressure.