Menu

New Data Attempt to Resolve Protein Dispute

The latest analysis on GDF11, a proposed antiaging protein, blames discrepancies in the literature on misreported doses and misinterpretation.

Oct 22, 2015
Kerry Grens

WIKIPEDIA, DR. S. GIROD, ANTON BECKERA protein called growth differentiation factor 11 (GDF11) has been at the center of a tug of war: some scientists have provided evidence that it declines with age, and that returning GDF11 to youthful levels can fix a heart problem in mice. Yet others have found no such relationship, and one group published evidence this year that GDF11 actually increases with age.

To figure out why there have been discrepancies in the data, Richard Lee of Harvard Medical School and his colleagues—the team that found GDF11 dropped with age—scrutinized a conflicting study and found the likely explanation to be a case of mistaken identity. Rather than measuring levels of GDF11, Lee’s group found, the other researchers were likely measuring immunoglobulin light chain. “It’s a misinterpretation,” Lee told The Scientist.

Novartis Research Institutes, which led the study that found GDF11 levels rising with age, did not respond to requests for comment. Lee told The Scientist he had pointed out the error to the Novartis team over the summer, but has not heard back.

This week (October 21), the Harvard group showed in Circulation Research that an antibody against GDF11 used in Western blot analyses also recognizes immunoglobulin, and that eliminating immunoglobulin from the assay wipes out the band. Mass spectra of the band also indicated that the signal came from immunoglobulin.

Steven Houser of Temple University School of Medicine, who was not involved in either study, says Lee’s data in support of a misinterpretation by Novartis are strong. “It looks like the Novartis group misidentified a band as GDF11,” he said. But he added that questions about GDF11’s effects on the heart are still unresolved.

Last month, Houser’s team reported evidence conflicting with Lee’s data on cardiac hypertrophy, or thickening of the heart muscle. Lee’s team had found that giving older mice a boost in GDF11 levels fixed their cardiac hypertrophy. Houser’s group, on the other hand, found no effect.

According to the Lee group’s latest paper, the difference might be due to variability in the concentration of GDF11. Originally, Lee’s team—as subsequently replicated by Houser’s—used a concentration of 0.1 mg/kg, but it turns out that the manufacturer had sent the Lee group variable concentrations. Now, the Harvard researchers have reported, a concentration of 0.5 mg/kg is the effective dose.

“They think the dose was higher than they realized. That’s troubling, to be honest,” Hauser told The Scientist. “If they knew the dose to be reported was not the right dose, there are ways to inform the field.”

Lee agreed there is still much to be learned about GDF11, and this latest study does not put questions about its activity to bed. “I think a lot of this is, early on in the field the reagents aren’t perfect, the assays aren’t perfect, so people get results that look like they’re opposing each other. . . . We need better assays, we need more science, we really just need to do more work.”

T. Poggioli et al., “Circulating growth fifferentiation factor 11/8 levels decline with age,” Circulation Research, doi:10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.115.307521, 2015.

April 2019

Will Car T Cells Smash Tumors?

New trials take the therapy beyond the blood

Marketplace

Sponsored Product Updates

Application of TruBIOME™ to Increase Mouse Model Reproducibility
Application of TruBIOME™ to Increase Mouse Model Reproducibility
With this application note from Taconic, learn about the effects of the microbiome on reproducibility and predictability and how TruBIOME™ helps researchers generate custom microbiota mouse models!
Getting More Consistent Results by Knowing the Quality of Your Protein
Getting More Consistent Results by Knowing the Quality of Your Protein
Download this guide from NanoTemper to learn how to identify and evaluate the quality of your protein samples!
Myth Busting: The Best Way to Use Pure Water in the Lab
Myth Busting: The Best Way to Use Pure Water in the Lab
Download this white paper from ELGA LabWater to learn about the role of pure water in the laboratory and the advantages of in-house water purification!
Shimadzu's New Nexera UHPLC Series with AI and IoT Enhancements Sets Industry Standard for Intelligence, Efficiency and Design
Shimadzu's New Nexera UHPLC Series with AI and IoT Enhancements Sets Industry Standard for Intelligence, Efficiency and Design
Shimadzu Corporation announces the release of the Nexera Ultra High-Performance Liquid Chromatograph series, incorporating artificial intelligence as Analytical Intelligence, allowing systems to detect and resolve issues automatically. The Nexera series makes lab management simple by integrating IoT and device networking, enabling users to easily review instrument status, optimize resource allocation, and achieve higher throughput.