While the approach has been used to correct mutations in a variety of cell lines, attempts to edit genes in human primary hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs)—important targets for treating a number of inherited blood disorders—have proved unsuccessful.
“The real hurdle was to achieve gene editing in cells relevant for [clinical] translation,” says Luigi Naldini of the San Raffaele Scientific Institute in Milan. The challenge is that homology-directed repair requires cells to be cycling, and, for the most part, HSCs are quiescent. Stimulating HSCs to divide induces differentiation, however, so the team “fine-tuned the conditions” to both expand HSCs and maintain their undifferentiated state, Naldini explains. These tweaks have now allowed his team to use ZFNs to rewrite a disease-causing mutation in HSCs from a patient with X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (X-SCID).
The group successfully repaired between 3 percent and 11 percent of the patient’s HSCs. While that may not sound like many cells, “it’s pretty exciting,” says Harry Malech of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases who was not involved in the study, because “it’s encouraging that you can do it at all.”
Improving the efficiency may be necessary to fix certain blood-based disorders, says Malech, but he adds that “for diseases like X-linked SCID . . . the goal can be quite low” because the corrected stem cells will likely be able to expand once inside the patient. (Nature, 510:235-40, 2014)
|TECHNIQUE||HOW IT WORKS||CLINICAL USE||RISK||REPLACEMENT GENE|
|Gene addition||Viral vector delivers a functional copy of the mutated gene to cells.||Numerous human trials ongoing||Viral vectors can integrate randomly into the genome and disrupt host genes.|| Less likely to have normal expression levels |
|Gene editing||Nucleases recognize and cut out the mutant DNA sequence. Homology-directed repair replaces it with a functional sequence.||Initial trials underway||Nucleases may cut off-target genomic sites and cause mutation, though this appears to be rare.||Very likely to have normal expression levels|