Sound Waves Aid Brain Tumor Treatment
Sound Waves Aid Brain Tumor Treatment

Sound Waves Aid Brain Tumor Treatment

In a small clinical study, focusing ultrasound beams on tumors in patients’ brains helped open the blood-brain barrier to facilitate drug delivery.

ruth williams
Ruth Williams

Ruth is a freelance journalist and regular correspondent for The Scientist, writing news for the website and monthly Modus Operandi articles for the magazine. Before freelancing, Ruth was a...

View full profile.

Learn about our editorial policies.

Oct 13, 2021

ABOVE: Pairs of brain scans show the uptake of radiolabeled tratuzumab into tumors (arrows) before (left) and after (right) focused ultrasound.

A first-in-human trial reported in Science Translational Medicine today (October 13) demonstrates delivery of an immunotherapy drug to metastatic brain tumors with the help of focused ultrasound. The targeted low-frequency sound waves temporarily opened the normally impenetrable blood-brain barrier at the sites of tumors in stage 4 breast cancer patients, enabling drug entry. Follow up analyses indicated the procedure also led to tumor shrinkage.

“It’s a really important step forward in this process of understanding how valuable focused ultrasound will be as a method to deliver drugs to the brain,” says neuroscientist Richard Daneman of the University of California, San Diego, who studies the blood-brain barrier but was not part of the research team.

“The fact that they did show increased drug delivery where they wanted to target—that is pretty cool,” adds neurosurgery researcher Choi-Fong Cho of Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Harvard Medical School, who also did not participate in the research.

The brain is a problematic organ to treat, explains Cho, because it has a built-in defense shield in the form of the blood-brain barrier—a specialized endothelial lining to the brain’s blood vessels that stops large molecules from exiting into the surrounding neural tissue. The barrier is highly effective at preventing pathogens and toxins from entering the brain, says Cho, but it also blocks drugs. Because of that, “when it comes to treating diseases in the brain,” she says, “it really poses a major challenge.”

One way around this issue is to inject therapeutics directly into the brain, but such injections are technically fraught and can require surgically creating an opening in the skull. So researchers sought a way to temporarily permeabilize the blood-brain barrier without the need for surgery—and over a decade ago, they discovered they could use sound.

Gas-filled lipid microbubbles, originally developed as a contrast agent for ultrasound imaging, are injected into the bloodstream and, when ultrasound beams are directed at a particular site, the bubbles in that region jiggle, disrupting the vessel walls. In animal studies, the technique, called focused ultrasound, has been used to treat brain diseases. But in humans, it had only been tested for feasibility and safety—to confirm that permeabilization occurs and quickly resolves.

See “Ultrasound Opens Blood-Brain Barrier in Alzheimer’s Patients

In this latest human study, neurosurgery researcher Nir Lipsman of Sunnybrook Research Institute and colleagues have taken the technology a step further, showing that focused ultrasound enables a drug to enter brain tumors and possibly even shrink them.

Lipsman’s team performed the technique on four female patients, aged between 31 and 56, who were all regularly receiving the immunotherapeutic drug trastuzumab to treat metastatic Her2-positive breast cancer. Her2-positive cancers are those in which the cells produce large amounts of human epidermal growth factor receptor 2, which fuels the cancer’s growth. Trastuzumab is a monoclonal antibody that blocks Her2. It can be effective at shrinking tumors around the body, but it doesn’t enter the brain, explains Lipsman.

See “New Understanding of Metastasis Could Lead to Better Treatments

The women were given a small quantity of radiolabeled trastuzumab along with their normal dose to enable imaging of the drug both before and after their brain tumors were targeted with the focused sound waves. Imaging the women’s brains with single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) revealed that the focused ultrasound roughly doubled the amount of radioactivity detectable in the brain lesions compared to baseline, says Lipsman, showing the drug had successfully gotten in.

The helmet used to deliver focused ultrasound beams to patients’ brain tumors

The procedure, which was performed multiple times in each patient, caused no severe adverse effects—all patients were discharged from the hospital the same day. Additionally, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) the following day confirmed the blood-brain barrier had closed.

Follow up MRIs performed over the following months showed that all of the women experienced shrinkages in brain tumor size, varying from 31 to 7 percent. There was no control group.

“It’s so difficult to make broad sweeping conclusions with regard to efficacy with only four patients but, that said, of course, it’s a promising signal,” says Lipsman, who adds he hopes large-scale controlled trials can begin soon.

Even without hard proof that the technique shrinks tumors, the paper is a major advance for focused ultrasound, says neurosurgeon Graeme Woodworth of the University of Maryland who was not involved in the project. It shows the technique can work with a large immunotherapy drug, he says, and for the first time tracks the location of the drug in patients. “Overall, it’s very exciting.”