Natural pathogenic bacteria populations can harbour mutator alleles (with high mutation rates) that may offer a selection advantage. In the March 30 Science, Giraud et al. describe a model to investigate the role of mutator alleles in influencing adaptation to complex environments in vivo (Science 2001, 291:2606-2608). They examined the colonization of the mouse gut by Escherichia coli strains with a high mutation rate due to a defective MutS protein. By examining bacteria in fecal samples they could follow total population sizes. Within the first two weeks of mouse infection, the mutator bacteria exhibit an advantage in gut colonization and adaptation. But at later stages the accumulation of deleterious mutations appears to affect bacterial competitiveness in secondary environments and transmission between hosts. Hence, high mutation rates may be beneficial for generating early adaptative mutations, but harmful once adaptation is achieved. These results provide a system to...