Menu

Fraudulent Paper Pulled

Nature retracts a study six years after an investigation found that the protein structures it reported were fabricated.

Jan 5, 2016
Bob Grant

WIKIMEDIA, NIKLAS BILDHAUERA paper on protein structures published in Nature in 2006 was retracted by the journal’s publisher yesterday (January 4), six years after an investigation conducted by the lead author’s institution found that the structures were fabricated. Neither Nature nor the paper’s authors have fully explained why it took so long to retract the study. “This is a pretty old story, I don’t know why Nature took so long,” coauthor Narayana Sthanam from the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB) told Retraction Watch. “Nature asked us maybe two months back, do I have any comment or objection for retracting.”

The retraction notice posted by Nature indicates that two of the paper’s six authors did not agree to voluntarily retract the paper; three agreed to the retraction, while one author did not respond. One of the coauthors who did not agree with the retraction, former UAB researcher M. Krishna Murthy, was found “solely responsible for the fraudulent data” by the UAB investigation.

The retracted Nature paper described the crystal structure of a protein called C3b, which plays a role in immune response pathways. The manuscript raised red flags soon after it was published, as it contradicted other published models. UAB launched an investigation into the discrepancies in 2006, and published its findings concerning misconduct on the part of Murthy in 2009. According to Retraction Watch, the paper has been cited more than 40 times.

November 2018

Intelligent Science

Wrapping our heads around human smarts

Marketplace

Sponsored Product Updates

Complete Pathology Solutions: Make Every Minute Count

Complete Pathology Solutions: Make Every Minute Count

From sample collection and handling, to fixation and processing, tissue staining, and covering all your IHC and water purification needs—you can have confidence in the quality of your results with MilliporeSigma's one-stop pathology solution.

Preparing Cell Or Tissue Lysates For ELISA Kits

Preparing Cell Or Tissue Lysates For ELISA Kits

RayBiotech manufactures over 2,000 high fully validated, GMP-compliant ELISA kits. In this blog post we explain how to prepare cell or tissue lysates for ELISA Kits.

Norgen Biotek Achieves Illumina Propel Certification as a Service Provider for Next Generation Sequencing

Norgen Biotek Achieves Illumina Propel Certification as a Service Provider for Next Generation Sequencing

Norgen Biotek Corp., an innovative privately held Canadian biotechnology company focusing primarily on nucleic acid and protein stabilization and purification, as well as providing high quality services to the scientific community, today announced that it has become Propel-Certified through Illumina as a Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) service provider.

Slice® Safety Cutters for Lab Work

Slice® Safety Cutters for Lab Work

Slice cutting tools—which feature our patent-pending safety blades—meet many lab-specific requirements. Our scalpels and craft knives are well suited for delicate work, and our utility knives are good for general use.