Menu

Scientists in Chile Protest Mummy Study

The Chilean government contends that the remains of a mummified fetus, recently sequenced by US researchers, were exhumed illegally.

Mar 29, 2018
Jim Daley

The "Atacama Skeleton," found in La Noria, Chile, in 2003S. BHATTACHARYA

Update (April 2): Genomics Research has released a statement defending its review and publication of the paper.

Last week (March 22), researchers reported the sequenced genome of a mummified fetus found in 2003 near Chile’s Atacama desert in Genome Research. Now, some Chilean scientists are condemning the study as unethical, and the Chilean National Monuments Council has begun an inquiry into whether the remains were illegally disinterred and smuggled out of the country (via The New York Times).

The Chilean Society of Biological Anthropology released a statement yesterday (March 28), in which it says the study ignored the basic ethical standards surrounding archaeology. “[A] study of similar characteristics where the remains of a fetus [were] unearthed from a current cemetery in a developed country would surely provoke other reactions,” the statement concludes.

“We had no involvement or knowledge of how the skeleton was originally obtained nor how it was sold or exported to Spain,” Atil Butte, a geneticist at Stanford and coauthor of the Genome Research study, tells The New York Times. “We had no reason to suspect in this case that this sample was illegally obtained.”

Óscar Muñoz, a local treasure-hunter, found the remains in 2003 in the abandoned village of La Noria. The mummy is unusual in that it is 6 inches long but has a fully formed skeleton. It also has 10 ribs instead of 12 and large eye sockets set in an oblong skull that tapers to a point. Its unique appearance fueled rumors that it was a nonhuman primate or even an extraterrestrial being. A private collector in Barcelona named Ramon Navia-Osorio eventually obtained the mummy, which was featured in a 2013 documentary that claimed it was an alien life form (via Science). Gary Nolan, a geneticist at Stanford, heard about the film and contacted its producers to offer to analyze the mummy's DNA; they agreed, and last week Nolan’s team published its results.

Whole-genome sequencing revealed that the remains were in fact those of a human female who had mutations in several genes linked with a constellation of diseases affecting stature, skull formation, and skeletal dysplasia. “I was amazed by how much you can tell from the genetic blueprint,” study coauthor Sanchita Bhattacharya, a bioinformaticist at the University of California, San Francisco, told The New York Times last week.

Cristina Dorador, a biologist at the University of Antofagasta, published an article earlier this week (March 25) in Etilmercurio, an online science publication, in which she notes that the researchers failed to meet the legal requirements for working on samples from Chile, such as obtaining permits and providing an ethical statement about the work. “Etilmercurio demands that the Chilean authorities, the academic community and civil society openly condemn the outrage continually committed over the years,” she writes.

Dorador writes that the Genome Research study is “peppered with mistakes” about the origin and wider context of the mummy that could have been avoided by contacting local experts, and that they ascribe Andean origin to a genetic signature of people from an island 2,500 kilometers south of the region.

Correction (March 30): The original version of this article erroneously referred to Cristina Dorador as Cristina Dorado; it has been corrected. The Scientist regrets this error.
 
 

January 2019

Cannabis on Board

Research suggests ill effects of cannabinoids in the womb

Marketplace

Sponsored Product Updates

FORMULATRIX® digital PCR technology to be acquired by QIAGEN
FORMULATRIX® digital PCR technology to be acquired by QIAGEN
FORMULATRIX has announced that their digital PCR assets, including the CONSTELLATION® series of instruments, is being acquired by QIAGEN N.V. (NYSE: QGEN, Frankfurt Stock Exchange: QIA) for up to $260 million ($125 million upfront payment and $135 million of milestones).  QIAGEN has announced plans for a global launch in 2020 of a new series of digital PCR platforms that utilize the advanced dPCR technology developed by FORMULATRIX combined with QIAGEN’s expertise in assay development and automation.
Application of CRISPR/Cas to the Generation of Genetically Engineered Mice
Application of CRISPR/Cas to the Generation of Genetically Engineered Mice
With this application note from Taconic, learn about the power that the CRISPR/Cas system has to revolutionize the field of custom mouse model generation!
Translational Models of Obesity, Dysmetabolism, Diabetes, and Complications
Translational Models of Obesity, Dysmetabolism, Diabetes, and Complications
This webinar, from Crown Bioscience, presents a unique continuum of translational dysmetabolic platforms that more closely mimic human disease. Learn about using next-generation rodent and spontaneously diabetic non-human primate models to accurately model human-relevant disease progression and complications related to obesity and diabetes here!
BiochemAR: an augmented reality app for easy visualization of virtual 3D molecular models
BiochemAR: an augmented reality app for easy visualization of virtual 3D molecular models
Have you played Pokemon Go? Then you've used Augmented Reality (AR) technology! AR technology holds substantial promise and potential for providing a low-cost, easy to use digital platform for the manipulation of virtual 3D objects, including 3D models of biological macromolecules.