Menu

Two Genetic Forensics Techniques Draw Fire

Defense attorneys allege New York City used “unreliable” methods on DNA evidence in thousands of cases.

Sep 12, 2017
Shawna Williams

INFOGRAPHIC BY JUDE BUFFUMCutting-edge DNA identification techniques used by the office of New York City’s chief medical examiner were less reliable than claimed, some experts say. The allegation comes in a letter sent by the Legal Aid Society and the Federal Defenders of New York, an organization of public defenders, ProPublica and The New York Times reported last week (September 4).

“I’m 100 percent convinced that there are many people who are incarcerated who were convicted with DNA evidence who are innocent,” Bicka Barlow, a lawyer with a background in genetics and molecular biology, tells the Times.

At issue in the letter are techniques called “high-sensitivity testing,” or low copy number analysis, which detects trace amounts of DNA, and the Forensic Statistical Tool (FST), a software program to calculate whether a given person’s genetic material is likely present in a sample of mixed DNA. The lab in the office of the chief medical examiner estimates it has used high-sensitivity testing on evidence for 3,450 cases and FST for 1,350 cases, the Times reports.

See “Forensics 2.0

Julie Fry, a lawyer with the Legal Aid Society, tells the Associated Press that the high-sensitivity testing technique is “like making a copy of a copy of a copy. Eventually it’s going to be faded.”

“And with FST, it’s a computer program,” she says. “We don’t have access to the code—and we can’t tell if it’s accurate or not. We don’t know what’s in the black box,” she said.

Former FBI forensic scientist Bruce Budowle has also criticized FST, testifying at a hearing a few years ago that “five-person mixtures can look like three-person,” according to the Times. “Four contributors can look like two-person mixtures. It’s almost impossible to actually be accurate.”

November 2018

Intelligent Science

Wrapping our heads around human smarts

Marketplace

Sponsored Product Updates

Complete Pathology Solutions: Make Every Minute Count

Complete Pathology Solutions: Make Every Minute Count

From sample collection and handling, to fixation and processing, tissue staining, and covering all your IHC and water purification needs—you can have confidence in the quality of your results with MilliporeSigma's one-stop pathology solution.

Preparing Cell Or Tissue Lysates For ELISA Kits

Preparing Cell Or Tissue Lysates For ELISA Kits

RayBiotech manufactures over 2,000 high fully validated, GMP-compliant ELISA kits. In this blog post we explain how to prepare cell or tissue lysates for ELISA Kits.

Norgen Biotek Achieves Illumina Propel Certification as a Service Provider for Next Generation Sequencing

Norgen Biotek Achieves Illumina Propel Certification as a Service Provider for Next Generation Sequencing

Norgen Biotek Corp., an innovative privately held Canadian biotechnology company focusing primarily on nucleic acid and protein stabilization and purification, as well as providing high quality services to the scientific community, today announced that it has become Propel-Certified through Illumina as a Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) service provider.

Slice® Safety Cutters for Lab Work

Slice® Safety Cutters for Lab Work

Slice cutting tools—which feature our patent-pending safety blades—meet many lab-specific requirements. Our scalpels and craft knives are well suited for delicate work, and our utility knives are good for general use.