Fraud: Journals must act now

Written byRichard Gallagher

| 1 min read

linkurl:Today?s science fraud revelation;http://www.the-scientist.com/news/display/22952/ is that a study published in __The Lancet__, purportedly demonstrating that common painkillers could protect against oral cancer, was pure fiction. The response of __The Lancet__ Editor Richard Horton, linkurl:as quoted by the BBC;http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/4617372.stm "The peer-review process is good at picking up poorly designed studies, but it is not designed to pick up fabricated research. Just as in society you cannot always prevent crime, in science you cannot always prevent fabrication." Hmmm. According to The Norwegian daily newspaper __Dagbladet__, 250 of the 908 people in Sudbo's study shared the same birthday. If journals can?t pick that kind of thing up, either by internal review or peer review, doubts about science's self-policing systems are well-founded. Horton mirrors the fatalism of Donald Kennedy, Editor of __Science__, in the wake of the Hwang debacle: "The public needs to understand that the journals and peer review are not perfect," he said. That?s first entry in understatement of the year. But what is he doing about it? The modest but worthwhile proposal from __Science__ is that authors will need to state their specific contributions. It?s nowhere near enough. Journals need to take a lead in combating fraud, yet Editors are distancing themselves from the issue. linkurl:An exception is __Journal of Cell Biology__;http://www.jcb.org/cgi/content/full/166/1/11 , which screens accepted manuscripts for evidence of image manipulation, in collaboration with a mathematician who is a specialist in art fraud. Why aren?t other journals doing this? And why isn?t the dragnet being widened to include a search of data for the telltale signatures of counterfeiting? That's what is needed. Right now, I?d settle for an acknowledgement from Editors that (a) there?s a problem, (b) they are going to do something about it.

Fraud: Journals must act now

The Scientist ARCHIVES

Become a Member of

Meet the Author

Richard Gallagher

Related Research Resources

Wooden Neurons: An Artistic Vision of the Brain

Research Resources

Podcasts

Webinars

Videos

Infographics

eBooks

Driving Innovation with Cell Culture Essentials

Driving Innovation with Cell Culture Essentials

Human iPSC-derived Models for Neurodegenerative Disease Research

Exploring the Inflammatory Tumor Microenvironment

Products

Product News

Beckman Coulter Life Sciences Introduces the Biomek i3 Benchtop Liquid Handler, a Small but Mighty Addition to its Portfolio of Automated Workstations

BRANDTECH® Scientific Announces Strategic Partnership with Copia Scientific to Strengthen Sales and Service of the BRAND® Liquid Handling Station (LHS)

Enter Our 2026 Top Innovations Contest

Biotium Expands Tyramide Signal Amplification Portfolio with Brighter and More Stable Dyes for Enhanced Spatial Imaging