Opinion: Louisiana shuns science

Governor Bobby Jindal and the state's local government officials are ignoring the input of Gulf Coast researchers in pushing ahead with plans to build sand berms to protect the Louisiana coast from oil.

The first segment of sand berms along
the northern section of the (submerged)
Chandeleur Island chain photographed
from about the same location and altitude
on 25th June (top), 2nd July (middle),
and 7th July (bottom)
Image: Courtesy of Len Bahr

The latest blow to the highly stressed landscape of the Mississippi River Delta was the Macondo Deep Horizon oil well blowout on April 20 of this year. This explosion killed eleven men and, until being capped on July 15, released an estimated 60,000 barrels a day of crude petroleum a mile beneath the gulf surface and about twenty miles southeast of the closest land.Absence of plans for responding to such a massive oil release, combined with panic and desperation among coastal residents, created an irresistible political opportunity for action on the part of an ambitious governor and his cabinet. Jindal and local government leaders seized the emergency created by the blowout to propose a physical barrier "solution" -- to pile up defensive sand berms. The rationale for this action is to intercept oil in waters from the Gulf before it can contaminate the wetlands, the fish and wildlife they nourish, the human population centers they protect, and the delta sediments they hold in place.The coast of Louisiana frames North America's largest delta, which has been rapidly shrinking and sinking for a century. River channelization, flood levees, upriver dams and coastal oil and gas production continue to take their toll, with a net loss of about 2,300 square miles of inundated landscape per year.Reduction in the subaerial delta landscape has made southern Louisiana more and more vulnerable to hurricanes. In August 2005, Hurricane Katrina crossed the hobbled coastal landscape to devastate New Orleans and coastal Mississippi, becoming the most damaging American hurricane of the past century. This storm washed away about 200 square miles of emergent wetlands, some of which have since recovered.About 80 miles of 6-foot-high sand berms are now under construction on the lower east and west sides of the Mississippi River. The total quantity of sand required to complete this project is said to be 56 million cubic yards -- the equivalent of 11.2 times the volume of the Superdome!Some of this sand is being dredged from the lower river channel, but most is being mined from shoals remaining from sunken barrier islands. Sand dredging deepens the subsurface profile and reduces hydraulic friction that formerly absorbed energy during approaching storm surges. An add-on to the sand barrier project was a proposal to partially fill a number of tidal passes -- places in the shoreline where ocean water makes its way inland on high tides -- using rocks. State officials justified these projects by dusting off longstanding but unfunded plans to nourish deltaic barrier shorelines on a massive scale, using sand dredged from the river and from 7,000 year-old offshore shoals. The prospect of charging BP for a scaled down version of this concept, sparked by dredging industry lobbyists, resulted in a back-of-the-envelope plan to create new linear sand features parallel to existing shorelines.The implied motive for these emergency sand and rock projects was presumably to restrict the wind-driven influx of oil-bearing gulf water by "shortening" the shoreline, using partial barricades to choke down pathways for the intrusion of floating oil and trap some oil on sand.Project proponents virtually ignored the extensive knowledge base of the Mississippi River delta in a rush to implement construction contracts quickly and with as little scientific scrutiny as possible. These proponents are apparently naive about basic hydrologic (tidal) processes. For example, they ignore the fact that reducing the cross sectional area by which tides currently operate will not change the volume of water exchanged during a tidal cycle; it will increase the current velocity (and scouring power) of the water.Reducing the influx of (oily) gulf water during flood tides would require one of two measures: 1) The tidal exchange volume could be reduced by elevating the bathymetry, raising the bottom profile into the intertidal zone by infilling estuarine shoals, using sediments pumped in on a massive scale. 2) Alternatively, tidal exchange could be eliminated by erecting a continuous floodwall to shut off all tidal exchange -- the so-called Dutch approach."Solution 1" would be worthwhile but infeasible and "solution 2" would be destructive and infeasible. The governor's approach, trying to partially block the pathways for oil intrusion, is just foolish.Minor storms have already washed away portions of the first sand berm segments constructed and permits to infill tidal passes have been denied by the US Army Corps of Engineers.__linkurl:Len Bahr,;http://www.gulfbase.org/person/view.php?uid=lbahr PhD, is a former LSU marine sciences faculty member who served 18 years as a coastal policy adviser to Louisiana governors from Buddy Roemer to Bobby Jindal. He edits linkurl:LaCoastPost.;http://lacoastpost.com/blog/ His e-mail is leonardbahr@gmail.com.__
**__Related stories:__***linkurl:Gulf scientists "on the sidelines";http://www.the-scientist.com/blog/display/57504/
[23rd June 2010]*linkurl:New NSF grants for oil spill;http://www.the-scientist.com/blog/display/57441/
[19th May 2010]*linkurl:Scientists brace for oil impact;http://www.the-scientist.com/blog/display/57410/
[17th May 2010]

Opinion: Louisiana shuns science

The Scientist ARCHIVES

Become a Member of

Meet the Author

Len Bahr

Related Research Resources

Nergal Networks: Where Friendship Meets Infection

Research Resources

Podcasts

Webinars

Videos

Infographics

eBooks

Unraveling Complex Biology with Five-Dimensional Multiomics

Resurrecting Plant Defense Mechanisms to Avoid Crop Pathogens

Seeing and Sorting with Confidence

Streamlining Microbial Quality Control Testing

Products

Product News

Agilent Unveils the Next Generation in LC-Mass Detection: The InfinityLab Pro iQ Series

Pioneering Cancer Plasticity Atlas will help Predict Response to Cancer Therapies

Alamar Biosciences, Alzheimer's Disease Data Initiative, and Gates Ventures Unite in Global Partnership to Advance Translational Research in Alzheimer's Disease

How Alderley Analytical are Delivering eXtreme Robustness in Bioanalysis