Skip to main content

No Arsenic-Based Life

Two new studies conclusively prove "arsenic-based" bacteria hailed by NASA researchers as a new form of life needs phosphate after all.

Written byHayley Dunning
| 1 min read

Register for free to listen to this article
Listen with Speechify
0:00
1:00

When NASA announced in December 2010 that its researchers had discovered a bacteria (GFAJ-1) that used arsenic in the backbone of its DNA instead of phosphate, the implications for alternative forms of life set the media and scientific community into a frenzy. An alternative DNA structure could mean an entirely new root for an evolutionary tree that grew up alongside the phosphate-bearing DNA structure used by every organism currently known on Earth.

But controversy over the methodology led many to challenge the result, and two papers published online today (July 9) in Science convincingly show that GFAJ-1 does in fact need phosphate to grow, and cannot survive when only arsenic is present instead. Furthermore, neither study found arsenic within or bound to the DNA of the bacteria.

One of the papers' authors, Rosie Redfield from the University of British Columbia, has been blogging about her progress in testing the claim, ...

Interested in reading more?

Become a Member of

The Scientist Logo
Receive full access to more than 35 years of archives, as well as TS Digest, digital editions of The Scientist, feature stories, and much more!
Already a member?
Add The Scientist as a preferred source on Google

Add The Scientist as a preferred Google source to see more of our trusted coverage.

Meet the Author

Related Topics

November digest cover
November 2026

Chemistry Meets Arcade Combat in “Reaction Rumble” Game

Choose your fighter! Enter the arena as chemical elements and dole out moves inspired by real-world reactions in this educational browser-based game.

View this Issue
From Pilot to Practice: Advancing Regulatory Reliance

From Pilot to Precedent: A Year of Regulatory Innovation through PRISM and What it Means for Cloud Adoption in Regulatory Submissions

DNAnexus
Thumbnail

Make It Local, Make It Last: The Evolution of mRNA Protein Replacement Therapy

Improving Western Blot Analysis of Biofluid Samples

Improving Western Blot Analysis of Biofluid Samples

Bio-Rad
Reducing AAV Sample Consumption With Multiwavelength SV-AUC

Reducing AAV Sample Consumption With Multiwavelength SV-AUC

​Beckman Coulter

Products

Sino Biological Logo

Sino Biological Advances AI-Designed Molecule Validation with 4RISE™

Abstract image of circles and concentric lines on a blue and pink background.

MX Analytical and Precision Balances: Effortless Weighing and Secure Data Handling

Mettler
3D multicolored conceptual image of antibody molecules

Premium BsAb: LC-MS-Assisted Bispecific Antibody Production with >98% Heterodimer Purity

WuXi Biologics
Abstract conceptual image of AI technology for medical science research.

Exploring a New Era of Pharmaceutical Innovation