Non-Concussive Head Hits Influence the Brain’s Microstructure
Non-Concussive Head Hits Influence the Brain’s Microstructure

Non-Concussive Head Hits Influence the Brain’s Microstructure

Comparing the brain scans of high-impact rugby players with those of athletes in noncontact sports, such as rowing and swimming, revealed tiny, yet significant, differences in the brain’s white matter.

Lisa Winter
Lisa Winter

Lisa Winter became social media editor for The Scientist in 2017. In addition to her duties on social media platforms, she also pens obituaries for the website. She graduated from Arizona State University, where she studied genetics, cell, and developmental biology.

View full profile.

Learn about our editorial policies.

Oct 1, 2020

ABOVE: Functional MRI scans show higher connectivity in the brains of rugby players in the off-season (top row) compared with non-contact athletes (bottom row). 
© NEUROLOGY, 95:e402–12, 2020


The paper
K.Y. Manning et al., “Longitudinal changes of brain microstructure and function in nonconcussed female rugby players,” Neurology, 95:e402–12, 2020.

Conversations about injuries in high-impact sports, such as football, hockey, and rugby, typically center around concussions, brain injuries that can affect memory, cognition, and balance. But not every collision yields a concussion, and even repeated, seemingly harmless impacts can alter the microstructure of white matter, myelinated neurons located deep in the brain, researchers reported in Neurology in July.

The study followed 104 female collegiate athletes in rugby, swimming, and rowing. Athletes wore headband sensors to measure the force of collisions during practices and games. None of the hits experienced by any athlete caused a concussion. Still, MRI and other imaging techniques showed differences in the white matter of rugby players who suffered low-impact collisions compared with the white matter of swimmers and rowers who didn’t suffer head hits. The differences were most noticeable in the corpus callosum, a nerve bundle that facilitates communication between the brain hemispheres, says study coauthor Ravi Menon, a neuroscientist at Robarts Research Institute in Canada.

Specifically, imaging during and after the athletes’ competitive seasons showed altered axon placement and increased functional connectivity among white matter neurons in the brains of the rugby players. Such neural rewiring, previous research suggests, could be a way for the brain to compensate for an injury.

Following athletes in the off-season is novel, says Pashtun Shahim, a physician at the National Institutes of Health Clinical Center who was not involved with the work. But, he cautions, “whether these changes in functional connectivity or white matter integrity are transient or persist over a long time is unclear.” Blood biomarkers that can be tracked noninvasively over longer periods of time, Shahim suggests, would be a more practical way to identify potential axon disruption in college athletes.