Unrest in the ACS

An anonymous Email that was circulated on October 10 calls into question the practices of the non-profit publishing giant, the American Chemical Society (ACS), which has long been under scrutiny.The Email, signed only by "ACS insider," was sent to college librarians, ACS administrators, and a science writing listserv. It said that the ACS is growing more corporate in structure and described how it manages the 36 chemical journals under its purview. Among other criticisms, the anonymous Emailer wrote that the bonuses given to ACS executives are tied to the profits of the publishing division, and such bonuses explain why the society has had such a strong stance against open-access publishing. The anonymous author responded to requests from The Scientist for more information about his or her identity only with "I just have to remain anonymous." He or she did not provide any confirmable evidence that bonuses to executives in the society were linked to profits in the publishing division. The Email is believable, Christopher Reed, distinguished professor of chemistry at the University of California, Riverside, and outspoken critic of the ACS, told The Scientist in an Email. "Staff are intimidated about speaking out, they must do so anonymously. The profit motive has distracted ACS management from its constitutional purpose."The Email called into question the high salaries and bonuses paid to ACS CEO Madeleine Jacobs, Chemical & Engineering News editor-in-chief Rudy Baum, and president of the ACS publishing division Brian Crawford, stating that the bonuses are directly proportional to the profits of the publishing division. Crawford is also the chairman of the Association of American Publishers, who, in August, launched the controversial Partnership for Research Integrity in Science and Medicine (PRISM) coalition, an anti-open-access group.A statement sent to The Scientist from Judith Benham, chair of the ACS board of directors, said: "The anonymous author makes erroneous and misleading claims about the compensation of these employees and alleges that the compensation is somehow related to the Society's position on open access."According the tax information submitted to the IRS for fiscal year 2005, three top executives, including Bob Massie, president of Chemical Abstracts Service (CAS) -- one of ACS's most successful publications -- make more than $750,000 a year, including bonuses. Benham added that compensation for executive employees is meant to be competitive, but not higher than other publishers in the market place, and that "no ACS employee's compensation is linked to the society's positions on open access." Baum declined to say whether his bonuses were linked to publishing profits, but only that the anonymous letter had more incorrect information in it than correct information. "When anonymous material comes into the office I throw it out right away," he told The Scientist.Several former ACS employees contacted by The Scientist, who wished to remain anonymous, said that while they were employees at the ACS, it was well known that upper level managers got bonuses that were linked to publishing profits. Sylvia Ware, former director of the ACS education division, declined to comment about bonus practice at the society. As reported in Nature in January, the ACS hired a high-profile public relations firm led by Eric Dezenhall -- made famous by working with the shamed Enron chief, Jeffrey Skilling, and ExxonMobil -- to create a PR campaign against the open-access movement. In Emails leaked to The New Scientist last month, Dezenhall outlined a plan for the "coalition" -- PRISM -- to strengthen their position against open access by summoning warnings of censorship from government involvement in publishing, in addition to appealing to "elite groups of decision makers." Andrea Gawrylewski mail@the-scientist.comLinks within this article:American Chemical Society https://portal.acs.org/portal/acs/corg/memberappChristopher Reed https://chem.ucr.edu/index.html?main=faculty&facsort=profile&faculty=reedMadeleine Jacobs https://pubs.acs.org/cen/staff/biomj.htmlRudy Baum https://pubs.acs.org/cen/staff/biorb.htmlS. Ainsworth, "Brian Crawford will head ACS publications," Chemical & Engineering News? August 2, 2007 https://pubs3.acs.org/cen/news/85/i32/8532news10.htmlA. McCook, "Going anti-anti open access," The Scientist, 12 September, 2007 https://www.the-scientist.com/blog/display/53584/PRISM https://www.prismcoalition.org/J. Giles, "PR's 'pit bull' takes on open access," Nature, 445, January 25, 2007. https://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v445/n7126/full/445347a.htmlDezenhall plan https://media.newscientist.com/data/images/ns/av/sss_publishing.pdf

The Scientist ARCHIVES

Become a Member of

Meet the Author

Andrea Gawrylewski

Related Research Resources

Epic Fail: Sea-Monkeys Sabotage Fieldwork

Research Resources

Podcasts

Webinars

Videos

Infographics

eBooks

Overcoming Immunotherapy Resistance in Liver Cancer

Optimizing NGS Library Preparation for Reliable Sequencing Data

Using TCR Repertoire Sequencing to Advance Immunology Research

Mapping Clonal Mosaicism in Aging Tissues

Products

Product News

Sino Biological Launches SuperNuclease ® Pro with Free Trial Program

Sino Biological Launches Precisely Characterized Full-Length p-Tau217 Protein to Advance Next-Generation Alzheimer’s Biomarker Assay Development

Resipher: Continuous Live-Cell Mitochondrial Respiration Monitoring in 96-Well Plates

The VAULT100 PRO: Inside the most advanced Stirling Ultracold ULT freezer ever built.