Dire Wolf De-Extinction Debate Divides Scientists

Created by editing the gray wolf genome, two dire wolves are the subject of vastly-differing opinions on what it means to bring back an extinct species.​​​​​

Rebecca Roberts,PhD
| 3 min read
A white dire wolf stands in a grassy enclosure in front of a pile of logs.
Register for free to listen to this article
Listen with Speechify
0:00
3:00
Share

In a preserve at an undisclosed location, two so-called dire wolves roam, eat, and play, blissfully unaware that their existence has ignited a heated scientific and ethical debate. According to Colossal Biosciences, a company focused on de-extinction projects, who created the now six-month-old animals, this is the first time a species has been brought back from extinction.

Two white dire wolf pups, one lying down and one standing.

Romulus and Remus are genetically identical but were birthed by different mothers. To accommodate their expected size, Colossal chose large mixed-breed dogs to carry the pups.

Colossal Biosciences

Named after the Romulus and Remus of Roman mythology—twin human brothers raised by a she-wolf—the Aenocyon dirus pups were created using multiplexed CRISPR editing of the genome of the extant gray wolf, Canis lupus. While some researchers hail this development as a breakthrough in conservation science, many are hesitant to jump on the de-extinction bandwagon. Others suggest that the animals are not dire wolves at all, but rather genetically modified gray wolves or hybrids.

So, what, exactly, does it mean to be a dire wolf? Colossal recently sequenced the first complete genome of the dire wolf from two fossils: a 13,000-year-old tooth and a 72,000-year-old inner ear bone. The currently unpublished analysis, which built on chief science officer Beth Shapiro’s 2021 study in Nature, revealed that the dire wolf genome shares 99.5 percent similarity with that of the gray wolf.1

Using endothelial progenitor cells taken from the blood of a gray wolf, the Colossal team incorporated 20 edits across 14 genes to produce traits that differentiate the dire wolf from the gray wolf. They then removed the nucleus from the edited cell and inserted it into the denucleated egg cell of a domestic dog. After the resulting cell developed into an embryo, it was implanted into a large domestic dog, who acted as a surrogate.

The genes Colossal edited were chosen because they influenced phenotypic factors, including size, skull shape, and musculature, as well as hair color, texture, and length. Herein lies the wolves’ perceived identity crisis. Paleoecologist Jacquelyn Gill of the University of Maine, who was not involved in the study, told Scientific American that the animals are not true dire wolves: “I have more than 14 Neandertal genes in me, and we wouldn’t call me a Neandertal.”

Gray wolf cells in a Petri dish are being genetically edited to contain dire wolf DNA.

Colossal’s de-extinction program was based on editing the genome of the gray wolf to incorporate regions of DNA from the dire wolf that are responsible for several of its characteristic features, such as its large size.

Colossal Biosciences

Shapiro and her colleagues disagree. “If we can look at this animal and see what it’s doing, and it looks like a dire wolf and acts like a dire wolf, I’m going to call it a dire wolf,” Shapiro said in an interview with Wired.

Long-term plans for Romulus and Remus, and their younger sister Khaleesi, haven’t been decided. Colossal says they are attempting to create more of the animals but don’t have plans for a breeding program. Scientists like Gill are skeptical of any potential introduction of dire wolves into the wild.

“I think the dire wolf is absolutely a symbol of hope,” bioethicist and Colossal advisor Alta Charo said in a video released by Colossal, noting that the technologies developed for the dire wolf de-extinction program have yielded a range of benefits that apply to conservation. Beyond the de-extinction of the dire wolf, Colossal hopes to inform conservation efforts for living species that are currently endangered, like the red wolf Canis rufus. Critically endangered, the red wolf has a paucity of genetic variation that Colossal intend to supplement with four pups they have produced using their cloning methods.

  1. Perri AR, et al. Dire wolves were the last of an ancient New World canid lineage. Nature. 2021;591(7848):87-91.

Keywords

Meet the Author

  • Rebecca Roberts,PhD

    Rebecca Roberts, PhD

    Rebecca Roberts is a science writer and communicator. She earned her PhD in molecular biology from the University of the Sunshine Coast in Australia and completed a two-year postdoctoral fellowship at Lund University in Sweden. Her writing focuses on gene editing technology, cell and gene therapies, and the regulatory space.

Share
You might also be interested in...
Loading Next Article...
You might also be interested in...
Loading Next Article...
Image of a woman in a microbiology lab whose hair is caught on fire from a Bunsen burner.
April 1, 2025, Issue 1

Bunsen Burners and Bad Hair Days

Lab safety rules dictate that one must tie back long hair. Rosemarie Hansen learned the hard way when an open flame turned her locks into a lesson.

View this Issue
Conceptual image of biochemical laboratory sample preparation showing glassware and chemical formulas in the foreground and a scientist holding a pipette in the background.

Taking the Guesswork Out of Quality Control Standards

sartorius logo
An illustration of PFAS bubbles in front of a blue sky with clouds.

PFAS: The Forever Chemicals

sartorius logo
Unlocking the Unattainable in Gene Construction

Unlocking the Unattainable in Gene Construction

dna-script-primarylogo-digital
Concept illustration of acoustic waves and ripples.

Comparing Analytical Solutions for High-Throughput Drug Discovery

sciex

Products

Atelerix

Atelerix signs exclusive agreement with MineBio to establish distribution channel for non-cryogenic cell preservation solutions in China

Green Cooling

Thermo Scientific™ Centrifuges with GreenCool Technology

Thermo Fisher Logo
Singleron Avatar

Singleron Biotechnologies and Hamilton Bonaduz AG Announce the Launch of Tensor to Advance Single Cell Sequencing Automation

Zymo Research Logo

Zymo Research Launches Research Grant to Empower Mapping the RNome