Skip to main content

Opinion: Hold Animal Use Committees Accountable for Their Failures

As a former committee member who now advises PETA, I believe that claims that the identities of committee members must be kept secret to protect their safety are unfounded.

Written byLisa Jones-Engel, PhD
| 7 min read
white rat on black background
Register for free to listen to this article
Listen with Speechify
0:00
7:00

Editor’s note: This opinion article is a response to “Opinion: Time to Take Animal Rights Harassment More Seriously” by Jim Newman of Americans for Medical Progress.

“Trust is the foundation for ethical treatment of animals in research.” This was the response that I received in an email from a longstanding member of the University of Washington Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC), on which I also served, after another bruising public meeting. I had raised pointed questions to principal investigators about uncontrolled variables in their proposed experiments, the impact their studies would have on animal welfare and husbandry, and whether the harms inflicted upon the animals were justified by the presumed benefits to humans.

That member said that I was confused about the role, function, and responsibilities of the IACUC and that the “internal decision processes within the OAW [Office of Animal Welfare] are not appropriate within a public ...

Interested in reading more?

Become a Member of

The Scientist Logo
Receive full access to more than 35 years of archives, as well as TS Digest, digital editions of The Scientist, feature stories, and much more!
Already a member?
Add The Scientist as a preferred source on Google

Add The Scientist as a preferred Google source to see more of our trusted coverage.

Meet the Author

  • Lisa Jones-Engel

    Lisa Jones-Engel, PhD is a primate scientist, Fulbright scholar and former academic insider within the U.S. primate research system, with more than four decades of experience spanning laboratory science, fieldwork, and global health. Her research has focused on zoonotic disease transmission at the human–primate interface. Now a chief science advisor to PETA she analyzes the scientific, regulatory, and biosecurity failures underlying primate experimentation.

    View Full Profile

Related Topics

The Scientist October Digest cover
October 2026

Antarctica’s Blood Falls Teems With Mysterious Microbial Life

Miles away from the closest ocean, marine microbes thrive in the red ice and mud around Blood Falls, offering clues to microbial adaptation and past climate events.

View this Issue
Evaluating Blood Biomarkers for Alzheimer’s Disease Staging

Evaluating Blood Biomarkers for Alzheimer’s Disease Staging

​Beckman Coulter
Find better biologics faster with Stunner and the AI Developability Workcell

Find better biologics faster with Stunner and the AI Developability Workcell

Unchained Labs
An image of microcentrifuge tubes arranged within colorful laboratory racks.

Choose clarity. Choose speed. Choose MyMass™

Refeyn
Characterizing LNP Heterogeneity With Super-Resolution Imaging

Characterizing LNP Heterogeneity With Super-Resolution Imaging

Oni

Products

Stellaromics Logo

Stellaromics Expands Pyxa Adoption as Instruments are Installed at Leading Research Institutions Across the U.S. and EuropeStellaromics, Inc., the leader in 3D

3D rendered chromatin with DNA helix in the background

CUTANA™ ATAC-seq Kit: Robust Results from Low Inputs

EpiCypher Logo
A monoclonal antibody surrounded by immune cells and red blood cells

CellRaft AIR: Find the Right Antibody-Producing Cells Faster

Cell Microsystems
Maxwell® Rapid ccfDNA Kit

Maxwell® Rapid ccfDNA Kit: Automated Purification of ccfDNA in Under 30 Minutes

Promega