When Researchers Sound the Alarm on Problematic Papers

Finding and reporting an irregularity in a published study can lead people down an unexpected path.

Written byShawna Williams
| 11 min read
Illustration of a person confused looking at a computer

Register for free to listen to this article
Listen with Speechify
0:00
11:00
Share

ABOVE: MODIFIED FROM © ISTOCK.COM, VECTORBIRD

Jennifer Byrne still feels stressed remembering the evening, six years ago, when she recognized the magnitude of the problem. It was a Saturday, and Byrne’s family members “were all out in the living room watching television, like normal people,” she recalls. At her computer in another part of the house, Byrne was on PubMed digging into a handful of suspiciously similar papers investigating an obscure human gene’s connection to various cancers. On a hunch, she plugged a combination of terms into PubMed’s search, including the name of a different gene containing a nucleotide sequence that she’d seen in two studies so far. Up popped around a dozen more of what looked like cookie-cutter papers.

“I just sat there and cried,” remembers the University of Sydney cancer researcher and director of biobanking for New South Wales Health Pathology. “I just went, ‘Oh, my God, like, ...

Interested in reading more?

Become a Member of

The Scientist Logo
Receive full access to digital editions of The Scientist, as well as TS Digest, feature stories, more than 35 years of archives, and much more!
Already a member? Login Here

Related Topics

Meet the Author

  • Shawna was an editor at The Scientist from 2017 through 2022. She holds a bachelor’s degree in biochemistry from Colorado College and a graduate certificate in science communication from the University of California, Santa Cruz. Previously, she worked as a freelance editor and writer, and in the communications offices of several academic research institutions. As news director, Shawna assigned and edited news, opinion, and in-depth feature articles for the website on all aspects of the life sciences. She is based in central Washington State, and is a member of the Northwest Science Writers Association and the National Association of Science Writers.

    View Full Profile

Published In

Online only cover of the The Scientist, September 2021 issue
September 2021

Mapping Covid

SARS-COV-2 wreaks havoc around the body

Share
Image of a woman with her hands across her stomach. She has a look of discomfort on her face. There is a blown up image of her stomach next to her and it has colorful butterflies and gut bacteria all swarming within the gut.
November 2025, Issue 1

Why Do We Feel Butterflies in the Stomach?

These fluttering sensations are the brain’s reaction to certain emotions, which can be amplified or soothed by the gut’s own “bugs".

View this Issue
Olga Anczukow and Ryan Englander discuss how transcriptome splicing affects immune system function in lung cancer.

Long-Read RNA Sequencing Reveals a Regulatory Role for Splicing in Immunotherapy Responses

Pacific Biosciences logo
Research Roundtable: The Evolving World of Spatial Biology

Research Roundtable: The Evolving World of Spatial Biology

Conceptual cartoon image of gene editing technology

Exploring the State of the Art in Gene Editing Techniques

Bio-Rad
Conceptual image of a doctor holding a brain puzzle, representing Alzheimer's disease diagnosis.

Simplifying Early Alzheimer’s Disease Diagnosis with Blood Testing

fujirebio logo

Products

Eppendorf Logo

Research on rewiring neural circuit in fruit flies wins 2025 Eppendorf & Science Prize

Evident Logo

EVIDENT's New FLUOVIEW FV5000 Redefines the Boundaries of Confocal and Multiphoton Imaging

Evident Logo

EVIDENT Launches Sixth Annual Image of the Year Contest

10x Genomics Logo

10x Genomics Launches the Next Generation of Chromium Flex to Empower Scientists to Massively Scale Single Cell Research